The Other Bennet Sister: A New Adaptation of a Classic Tale

"The Other Bennet Sister," a 10-part television series adapted from Janice Hadlow's 2020 bestseller, reimagines the life of Mary Bennet, the often-overlooked sister from Jane Austen's "Pride and Prejudice." The series, produced by Sarah Quintrell with additional writing by Maddie Dai, aims to explore Mary's character in depth, contrasting her experiences with those of her more celebrated sisters, Jane, Elizabeth, Lydia, and Kitty.

The Guardian

The narrative begins with the Bennet family reacting to the news that Netherfield Park has been let to a wealthy single man, sparking excitement among the sisters. While Jane and Elizabeth engage with the news, Mary, portrayed by Ella Bruccoleri, faces neglect and ridicule from her family. Her attempts to participate in conversations are dismissed, and her physical appearance, particularly her "ruddy complexion," is used to justify her exclusion from the marriage market. This portrayal of Mary highlights her struggles for acceptance and recognition within her own family.

The Guardian

The series emphasizes the dynamics within the Bennet family, particularly the dismissive attitude towards Mary. Mrs. Bennet, played by Ruth Jones, is depicted as overly focused on her other daughters' prospects, often at Mary's expense. For instance, when Mr. Sparrow, an optician who shows interest in Mary, is discouraged from pursuing her due to her family's concerns about social standing, it underscores the societal pressures that dictate the characters' lives. This treatment of Mary is described as "farcical" and "tremendously boring," suggesting that the series may overemphasize her plight.

The Guardian

As the series progresses, Mary's character begins to develop when she is sent away to work as a governess. This change allows her to cultivate her interests and personality, providing a contrast to her earlier portrayal. Critics note that while the initial episodes may feel light and lacking in substance, the series gains depth as Mary's character evolves. Bruccoleri's performance is highlighted as a strong point, bringing charm and complexity to the role.

The Guardian

Critics have responded to the adaptation with mixed feelings. While some appreciate the effort to give Mary a more prominent role, others argue that the portrayal of her struggles can become exaggerated. The series is described as suitable for its pre-watershed time slot, yet some viewers may find it lacking in depth during its early episodes.

The Guardian

• “The girl never gets a break.” — The Guardian Reviewer

The Guardian

• “If I were Mary, this would present me with the opportunity for vengeance that I had been waiting for my whole life, but she is a better woman than I and agrees to keep her bum on the nearest chaise for the rest of the ball.” — The Guardian Reviewer

The Guardian

• “Matters improve for both Mary and the viewer when she is sent away to be a governess and is allowed to develop some character and interests.” — The Guardian Reviewer

The Guardian

Despite its initial shortcomings, "The Other Bennet Sister" offers a fresh perspective on a beloved classic, inviting viewers to empathize with Mary Bennet's journey. As the series unfolds, it promises to reveal the complexities of her character, making it a noteworthy adaptation for fans of Austen's work.

The Guardian