Ryan McMahon's Surprising Role as Yankees' Emergency Shortstop

As the New York Yankees prepare for the upcoming regular season, the team's roster is nearly finalized, with only a few critical decisions remaining. The Yankees are set to begin their season in less than ten days, and while the majority of the roster is healthy, the absence of three-year veteran shortstop Anthony Volpe due to left shoulder surgery has prompted a notable adjustment. José Caballero is expected to take on the starting shortstop role, but the Yankees face a challenge with limited depth at this position.

Newsweek

In a surprising development, former All-Star third baseman Ryan McMahon is likely to serve as the Yankees' emergency shortstop early in the season. McMahon, who has played at various infield positions throughout his nine-year career, has only made two prior appearances at shortstop. This spring, he has participated in multiple games at the position, showcasing his athleticism but also displaying uncertainty in decision-making.

Newsweek

Infield defense coach Dan Fiorito has been working closely with McMahon, providing him with a crash course on the fundamentals of playing shortstop, particularly focusing on cutoffs and positioning. Despite mixed results during his limited appearances, McMahon's strong arm and defensive skills make him a viable option should the Yankees need to rely on him before Volpe's anticipated return in May.

Newsweek

The Yankees' coaching staff has expressed confidence in McMahon's ability to adapt to the shortstop role, emphasizing his defensive capabilities. Brendan Kuty from The Athletic noted, "McMahon has looked capable athletically, but at times unsure in his decisions." This sentiment reflects the team's cautious optimism regarding McMahon's transition.

Newsweek

While some analysts support McMahon's emergency role, others express concern over the Yankees' lack of depth at shortstop. Critics argue that relying on a player with limited experience at the position could pose risks, especially in high-pressure situations during the early part of the season.

Newsweek

As the Yankees finalize their roster, all eyes will be on how McMahon performs in the emergency shortstop role. The team hopes that Volpe will return to full health by May, alleviating the need for McMahon to step in. Until then, the Yankees will monitor McMahon's progress and readiness to fill in as needed.

Newsweek

• “Last week, infield defense coach/first-base coach Dan Fiorito sat with McMahon and gave him a crash course on the basics of playing shortstop, focusing especially on cutoffs and positioning,” — Brendan Kuty, The Athletic

Newsweek