Exploring the Darkly Comedic World of *Forbidden Fruits*

*Forbidden Fruits*, directed by Meredith Alloway, is a dark comedy set in a Dallas mall, where a group of young witches navigates the complexities of sisterhood and ambition within a hypercapitalist environment. The film, adapted from Lily Houghton’s play *Of The Women Came The Beginning Of Sin, And Through Her We All Die*, features a cast led by Lili Reinhart as Apple, the dominant leader of the coven, alongside Lola Tung as the naive newcomer Pumpkin, Victoria Pedretti as Cherry, and Alexandra Shipp as Fig. The narrative unfolds through Pumpkin's perspective, revealing the dynamics and secrets of this fashion-forward group.

Paste Magazine

The film's humor is driven by the interactions among the four witches, particularly the sharp comedic timing of Pedretti, who portrays Cherry as a "horny airhead blonde." The dialogue, infused with the signature style of producer Diablo Cody, is characterized by rapid-fire quips and clever punchlines. However, the film's plot occasionally falters when it shifts focus from humor to narrative depth, particularly regarding the tragic fate of a former employee, Pickle, and the motivations behind Pumpkin's infiltration of the group.

Paste Magazine

While *Forbidden Fruits* excels in its comedic elements and character dynamics, it struggles with establishing a cohesive horror atmosphere. The film is primarily an R-rated comedy, with violent moments presented as humorous rather than terrifying. Critics note that the film's exploration of themes such as betrayal and conformity is somewhat limited, as the witches primarily target nonconformers rather than embodying a more rebellious spirit. This focus on brand-name assimilation among the characters may resonate with younger audiences but also restricts the film's broader critique of societal norms.

Paste Magazine

The film has been described as a "must-watch" for audiences who enjoy a blend of horror and comedy, particularly appealing to fans of platforms like Shudder and slumber party gatherings. Critics have highlighted the film's potential to cultivate a cult following due to its unique blend of outrageous fashion, witty dialogue, and strong performances.

Paste Magazine

• “Adapted by Alloway and playwright Lily Houghton from Houghton’s Of The Women Came The Beginning Of Sin, And Through Her We All Die (admittedly, not as snappy a title), Forbidden Fruits is a conversational film, not at all driven by its hiccupy plot or even an especially eerie atmosphere.” — Paste Magazine

Paste Magazine

• “If you don’t worry about the story and just immerse yourself in the gags, Alloway’s film is a must-watch for the Venn diagram overlap between Shudder subscribers and the slumber party crowd.” — Paste Magazine

Paste Magazine

*Forbidden Fruits* presents a fresh take on the witch genre, combining humor with a critique of consumer culture. While it may not fully deliver on its narrative ambitions, the film's engaging performances and sharp dialogue ensure it will resonate with its target audience, making it a noteworthy addition to the contemporary comedy landscape. The film is set to be released on March 27, 2026.

Paste Magazine