The Rise of James Fishback and the Gooning Subculture Among Gen Z Republicans

James Fishback, a candidate for the GOP nomination for governor of Florida, has garnered significant media attention despite his low polling numbers. His controversial views, which include antisemitic conspiracy theories and derogatory remarks about fellow Republican Rep. Byron Donalds, have positioned him as a polarizing figure. Notably, Fishback has found considerable support among younger conservatives, particularly males aged 18-32, where he polls at 32%. His campaign events attract large crowds, often filled with high school students, indicating a growing enthusiasm among Gen Z Republican men.

Salon

Fishback's appeal is intertwined with a subculture known as "gooning," which is characterized by an obsession with excessive masturbation and a misogynistic worldview. This phenomenon has been linked to the broader manosphere and male supremacist communities, where heterosexuality is often framed as a struggle for dominance over women. The fixation on platforms like OnlyFans, where many young men perceive women as "hoes," reflects a deeper societal anxiety regarding traditional gender roles and sexual relationships.

Salon

The discourse surrounding gooning reveals a troubling intersection between porn culture and radical right ideologies. Critics argue that many young men within this subculture express a desire for sexual gratification solely through masturbation, often accompanied by aggressive fantasies about women. This perspective reduces women to mere objects of sexual desire, further entrenching the belief that male heterosexuality is degrading. Influencers within the manosphere, including Fishback, perpetuate these ideas, framing women's financial independence through platforms like OnlyFans as a threat to traditional gender roles.

Salon

Critics highlight that the gooning culture is not merely a reaction to the existence of sex work but rather a response to the changing dynamics of gender and power in society. The rise of women in the workforce and their ability to choose partners based on preference rather than necessity challenges the traditional views held by many young conservative men. This shift is often scapegoated onto platforms like OnlyFans, which are seen as undermining women's roles as caregivers and homemakers.

Salon

Fishback's campaign has attempted to frame his proposed 50% "sin tax" on OnlyFans creators as a moral initiative aimed at reshaping societal behavior. However, his language and the underlying sentiments expressed by supporters suggest a deeper-rooted anger towards women who assert their independence and reject traditional roles.

Salon

• “There are no women hoeing out on the internet in Saudi Arabia.” — James Fishback, GOP Candidate

Salon

• “When I look at this overlap between porn culture and the radical right, I don’t see these men expressing a desire to have sex with or even kiss or cuddle the women they like,” — Michael Edison Hayden, Journalist

Salon

• “They can kind of only conceive of human relationships in patterns of dominance and violence.” — Robert Evans, Podcast Host

Salon

The rise of figures like James Fishback and the gooning subculture among Gen Z Republicans highlights a significant cultural shift within the party. This trend reflects broader societal tensions regarding gender, power, and sexuality. As these young men grapple with their identities in a rapidly changing world, their fixation on misogyny and sexual dominance may hinder their ability to form healthy relationships with women. The implications of this cultural phenomenon extend beyond individual attitudes, potentially influencing the future direction of conservative politics in America.

Salon