Full Breakdown
Mysterious Noise Disturbance Torments Edgewater Residents
3/21/2026, 9:10:44 AM
Overview of the Situation
Residents of Edgewater, New Jersey, have been enduring a persistent and mysterious noise disturbance that many believe is emanating from Manhattan, approximately one mile away. The noise, described as ear-splitting music, has been reported for weeks, particularly on Saturday nights, causing significant distress among local families.
Timeline of Events
The noise first disrupted the community in October 2025, with reports of loud music starting around 11:30 p.m. and continuing until 5 a.m. This phenomenon seemed to be an isolated incident until it reoccurred in February 2026 for four consecutive weekends, prompting over 100 complaints to the Edgewater Police Department.
Key Locations Involved
The Edgewater Police initially attributed the noise to Skinny’s Cantina on the Hudson, a nightclub located in West Harlem. However, the establishment has been closed since the beginning of 2026 following its sale to a new owner, raising questions about the actual source of the noise. Joseph Licul, the previous owner, confirmed that there has been no activity at the venue since its closure.
Official Responses
Edgewater police have communicated with the New York Police Department (NYPD) regarding the noise complaints. However, the NYPD has not confirmed the source of the disturbance, leading to frustration among Edgewater residents. One local expressed dissatisfaction with the response from the NYPD, stating, “Every time I call [the NYPD], they’re like, ‘Okay, we’re going to go check it out,’ but they’re like, they don’t sound too sure.”
Criticism & Opposition
Residents have voiced their concerns about the lack of effective communication and action between the Edgewater Police and the NYPD. Many feel that their complaints are not being taken seriously, with one neighbor remarking on the apparent confusion among authorities: “It’s like the first time they’ve heard of this, right? They’re clueless.” This sentiment reflects a broader frustration with the inability to resolve the issue, leaving residents anxious about the potential for future disturbances.
Conflicting Reports & Gaps
While Edgewater police have linked the noise to Skinny’s Cantina, the NYPD has not confirmed this connection or identified any alternative sources. This discrepancy highlights a communication breakdown between the two law enforcement agencies, contributing to the residents' ongoing distress.
Conclusion
As of now, Edgewater residents have experienced a brief respite from the noise, enjoying a silent Saturday recently. However, the uncertainty surrounding the source of the disturbance and the lack of coordinated response from law enforcement leave many in the community skeptical about the long-term resolution of this issue.
