The Impact of Kelly Clarkson's Tweet on Taylor Swift's Music Ownership

In June 2019, the music industry witnessed a significant upheaval when talent manager Scooter Braun acquired Big Machine Label Group for approximately $300 million. This acquisition included the master recordings of Taylor Swift's first six studio albums, a situation Swift described as her "worst case scenario." Swift, who signed with Big Machine at the age of 15, had long sought to buy her masters but was repeatedly denied. The recordings represented not just her music but pivotal moments of her adolescence and early adulthood.

NewsweekKelly Clarkson's Twitter Tip That Turned Taylor Swift Into the Ultimate Music Industry Boss Resurfaces

In response to the acquisition, Kelly Clarkson tweeted a strategic suggestion for Swift: re-record her songs to diminish the value of the original recordings. Clarkson's idea was to release new versions with updated artwork and incentives for fans to choose the re-recordings over the originals. This approach aimed to make the old recordings less appealing by offering something better. Swift embraced this strategy, launching the "Taylor's Version" project in November 2020. The re-releases of albums such as *Fearless*, *Red*, *Speak Now*, and *1989* debuted at #1 on the Billboard 200, while the original versions lost streaming traction.

Kelly Clarkson's Twitter Tip That Turned Taylor Swift Into the Ultimate Music Industry Boss ResurfacesNewsweek

The culmination of Swift's efforts came in May 2025, when she successfully purchased her masters back from Shamrock Capital, regaining ownership of her recordings, music videos, album art, and unreleased songs. At this point, only two albums remained unreleased as "Taylor's Version": *Reputation* and her self-titled debut from 2006. Swift disclosed that while her debut is fully re-recorded, *Reputation* remains a work in progress due to its emotional significance.

Newsweek

Clarkson confirmed the impact of her tweet in an interview, stating, "She's a very smart businesswoman. If they're going to find a loophole, you find a loophole. And she did it." Swift expressed her gratitude towards Clarkson, sending her flowers and a cardigan after the re-release of *1989*.

Kelly Clarkson's Twitter Tip That Turned Taylor Swift Into the Ultimate Music Industry Boss Resurfaces

While the re-recording strategy has been largely praised, some critics argue that the music industry should prioritize artists' rights and ownership from the outset, rather than relying on reactive measures. The situation has sparked discussions about the treatment of artists in contractual agreements and the importance of transparency in the industry.

Kelly Clarkson's Twitter Tip That Turned Taylor Swift Into the Ultimate Music Industry Boss Resurfaces

As Swift continues to navigate her re-recording project, the future of her remaining albums remains uncertain. Both *Reputation* and her debut album are anticipated, but their release timelines are not imminent, reflecting the emotional complexities involved in revisiting her past work.

Newsweek

• “This is what happens when you sign a deal at fifteen to someone for whom the term 'loyalty' is clearly just a contractual concept.” — Taylor Swift

Newsweek

• “Make the old recordings worth less by making something better.” — Kelly Clarkson

Newsweek

• “She's a very smart businesswoman,” — Kelly Clarkson

Newsweek