Elizabeth Eddy's Retirement and Controversial Stance on Women's Sports

Elizabeth Eddy, a former midfielder in the National Women's Soccer League (NWSL), announced her retirement after an 11-year professional career, reflecting on the consequences of her controversial stance regarding sex-based eligibility standards in women's sports. Eddy's decision to speak out on this issue, which she believed was vital for the future of women's soccer, led to significant backlash, both from fans and within her own team.

OutKick

In October 2022, Eddy published an essay advocating for the NWSL to adopt sex-based eligibility standards to protect women's sports. This decision was not made lightly; Eddy had wrestled with the potential repercussions, including the risk of backlash from the league and her peers. Her concerns were heightened after her team, Angel City FC, lost a scrimmage against a U14 boys' team, prompting her to question the physical disparities in competition.

OutKick

Eddy's perspective has been met with mixed reactions. While some teammates and peers privately expressed support for her views, they feared public backlash and potential ostracization. Eddy noted that the NWSL has embraced a more inclusive stance towards trans-identifying and DSD (Differences of Sexual Development) athletes, a position supported by prominent players like Megan Rapinoe and Alex Morgan. Eddy criticized this trend, suggesting that social and political agendas have overshadowed the integrity of women's sports.

OutKick

Eddy faced intense criticism following her essay, with some labeling her views as transphobic. She described the environment within the league as one where diverse opinions are not welcomed, stating, "It was pretty brutal." The media's portrayal of her essay, particularly the imagery used, further complicated her situation, as it did not align with her intentions.

OutKick

In her retirement announcement, Eddy expressed gratitude for her career and acknowledged the challenges she faced. She stated, "I’m feeling really settled and very excited for the future," emphasizing her commitment to advocating for women's exclusivity in sports. Eddy believes that dialogue is essential for progress, stating, "People have to choose to come together on both sides."

OutKick

Post-retirement, Eddy is shifting her focus to advocacy work, engaging in professional surfing and participating in local governance. She aims to promote women's sports and encourage young female athletes to voice their beliefs. Eddy's future endeavors include speaking at national events and participating in local council meetings, emphasizing the importance of representation and dialogue in sports.

OutKick

• "I was willing to be like, hey, 11 years I've given to something, and that's OK." — Elizabeth Eddy, Former NWSL Player

OutKick

• "It’s really important that we try and have a seat at the same table." — Elizabeth Eddy

OutKick

• "If the NWSL isn't willing to protect women, then they need to change the name to the National Open Soccer League." — Elizabeth Eddy

OutKick

Eddy's retirement marks a significant moment in the ongoing debate surrounding gender and competition in women's sports, highlighting the complexities and challenges faced by athletes who advocate for change.

OutKick