Raoul Peck's Documentary "Orwell: 2+2=5" Examines the Enduring Relevance of George Orwell

Raoul Peck's documentary, "Orwell: 2+2=5," explores the lasting significance of George Orwell's work, particularly his seminal novel, *Nineteen Eighty-Four*. The film highlights the concept of "Orwellian" truth manipulation, exemplified by the phrase "two and two make five," which has become a political meme in contemporary discourse. Through readings of Orwell's prose by actor Damian Lewis, the documentary juxtaposes Orwell's frail health during the creation of his masterwork with the physicality often emphasized by authoritarian regimes.

The GuardianOrwell: 2+2=5 — FILM REVIEW

The film delves into Orwell's early life, including his experiences as a policeman in Burma, which shaped his views on colonialism and state-sanctioned cruelty. Peck incorporates archival footage and photographs to illustrate Orwell's background and the socio-political climate of his time. The documentary also draws parallels between Orwell's predictions and modern political figures, including Donald Trump, Viktor Orbán, Narendra Modi, Benjamin Netanyahu, and Vladimir Putin, suggesting that Orwell's insights remain relevant in today's world.

The Guardian

Critics have pointed out several shortcomings in Peck's approach. Some argue that the film does not sufficiently address the complexities of Orwell's character, including his past antisemitic tendencies and his controversial decision to inform British authorities about individuals he deemed "crypto-communists." Additionally, the documentary has been criticized for lacking new insights, as many viewers are already aware of Orwell's relevance to contemporary issues. The reliance on existing footage and the absence of fresh perspectives have led some to view the film as misguided.

The Guardian

Peck's documentary has garnered mixed reviews, with some praising its heartfelt tribute to Orwell while others deem it lacking in originality. Critics have noted that while the film effectively showcases Orwell's literary prowess, it fails to explore the broader implications of his work on current totalitarian regimes, particularly in relation to contemporary theocracies.

The Guardian

• “But Orwell’s complications don’t compromise his genius for truth-telling.” — Anonymous Critic

The Guardian

• “One lies in the simple fact that the relevance of Orwell’s views to our present age is something that most of us have come to recognise already so that Peck’s film has nothing new to say.” — Anonymous Critic

Orwell: 2+2=5 — FILM REVIEW

As discussions surrounding the themes presented in "Orwell: 2+2=5" continue, audiences may anticipate further explorations of Orwell's work in relation to modern political landscapes. The documentary's reception could inspire additional scholarly and artistic endeavors that seek to unpack the complexities of Orwell's legacy in the context of contemporary governance and societal challenges.

The Guardian