Israeli Filmmaker Nadav Lapid's "Yes": A Satirical Critique of Israeli Society

Nadav Lapid's film "Yes" serves as a satirical exploration of Israeli life, particularly the experiences of Jewish Israelis following the October 7th attacks. The narrative centers around a young Tel Aviv couple, Y and Yasmine, who navigate the complexities of their artistic aspirations amidst a backdrop of societal chaos and moral compromise.

New Yorker

The film opens with Y, a jazz pianist, and Yasmine, a dancer, performing as disco clowns at a lavish party for the affluent and politically connected. Their antics, which include provocative performances and sexual encounters, set the stage for a deeper commentary on the state of Israeli society. The couple's encounter with an I.D.F. commander during a song battle highlights the absurdity of militarism intertwined with entertainment. The film culminates in Y's decision to accept a lucrative job from a Russian Jewish oligarch, tasked with composing an anthem glorifying Israel's military actions in Gaza. This choice marks a pivotal moment where Y grapples with his moral integrity.

New Yorker

Y's internal struggle is central to the film's narrative. As he reflects on his role as a father to his infant son, Noah, he confronts the bleak future he perceives for Israel. His philosophical musings reveal a tension between rebellion and acceptance, culminating in the realization that submission may equate to happiness. This paradox illustrates the complexities of identity and complicity within a society facing existential challenges.

New Yorker

While "Yes" has been praised for its bold satire, it has also faced criticism for its portrayal of Israeli life and military actions. Some viewers argue that the film's depiction of moral decay and complicity may oversimplify the nuanced realities of Israeli society. Critics contend that Lapid's approach could alienate audiences who seek a more balanced representation of the country's struggles and achievements.

New Yorker

In discussing the film, Lapid has emphasized its intent to provoke thought and discussion about the moral dilemmas faced by individuals in contemporary Israel. He has stated that "Yes" is not merely a critique but an exploration of the human condition within a specific cultural context.

New Yorker

• “Submission is happiness,” — Nadav Lapid, Filmmaker

New Yorker

The release of "Yes" is expected to spark further discussions about Israeli identity and the implications of military actions on personal and societal levels. As audiences engage with the film, it may lead to broader conversations about the role of art in reflecting and challenging societal norms.

New Yorker