AI-Assisted Travel: A Mixed Experience in Saltburn-by-the-Sea

Travel reporter Dawn Gilbertson undertook an experiment using Google's Gemini chatbot to plan a two-night trip from London to Saltburn-by-the-Sea, a lesser-known Victorian-era resort town on England's northeast coast. Gilbertson committed to following the AI-generated itinerary without conducting any external research, aiming to evaluate the effectiveness of AI in travel planning.

Newser

The trip, which was marketed by Gemini as a budget-friendly alternative to Italy's Amalfi Coast, featured a variety of experiences. While the itinerary included a "walkable" route from the train station, Gilbertson encountered significant challenges, including high winds and rain that made the walk perilous. Additionally, a seafood dinner recommended by the bot was unavailable due to winter hours, and the return journey was complicated by rail engineering work that the AI flagged too late.

Newser

Despite these setbacks, the trip also yielded positive experiences. Gilbertson enjoyed cliffside hiking, sampled a local dish known as chicken "Parmo," and even took a dip in the frigid North Sea. She noted that she encountered friendly locals and their dogs at various stops, enhancing her overall experience.

Newser

One notable shortcoming of the AI planning was its failure to suggest a mobile sauna that Gilbertson discovered independently. When she inquired about this oversight, Gemini acknowledged it as a "massive oversight" in the itinerary. This incident highlighted the limitations of AI in capturing spontaneous experiences that can enrich travel.

Newser

Gilbertson concluded that while AI can serve as a useful tool for generating ideas, it should not replace real-time checks or the element of serendipity in travel. She emphasized the importance of leaving room in itineraries for unexpected finds, suggesting that human intuition and flexibility remain crucial in travel planning.

Newser

Critics of AI travel planning argue that reliance on technology can lead to missed opportunities and challenges that a human planner might better navigate. The experience shared by Gilbertson serves as a cautionary tale about the potential pitfalls of depending solely on AI for travel arrangements.

Newser

• "AI is a useful idea machine, but not a substitute for real-time checks—or serendipity." — Dawn Gilbertson, Travel Reporter

Newser

• "I asked Gemini why it didn't recommend this and it called it a 'massive oversight' of the ultimate Saltburn experience." — Dawn Gilbertson, Travel Reporter

Newser

This exploration of AI in travel planning underscores both the potential benefits and limitations of using technology in personal experiences, suggesting a balanced approach that incorporates both AI insights and human spontaneity.

Newser