Story perspectives

98-Year-Old Judge Appeals Suspension as Conduct Issues Rise

3/29/2026

Center

Newman Appeals Suspension

Pauline Newman, a 98-year-old federal judge, is appealing to the Supreme Court to restore her position after a three-year suspension due to competency concerns, despite not being found incompetent.
The Supreme Court's decision to hear her case remains uncertain, as it accepts few cases.
Separately, the South Carolina Supreme Court suspended Judge Darrell Scott Fisher for 30 days for improper communication in a restraining order case, where he admitted wrongdoing.
Fisher plans to retire in 2026, underscoring ongoing discussions about judicial conduct and age in the legal system.

Left

Bevin Faces Contempt

Former Kentucky Governor Matt Bevin faces a contempt warrant for failing to provide financial records in a child-support case involving his son Jonah Bevin.
The March 27 hearing was postponed after Bevin asked to remove Judge Angela Johnson, alleging bias.
Jonah Bevin, now 19 and in temporary housing, seeks stability and support amid the delays.
Judge Peter Charleton retired from the Irish Supreme Court, urging more concise proceedings.

History

Historical Context

The 1975 Supreme Court ruling in "Furman v. Georgia" heightened scrutiny of judicial competency, prompting the American Bar Association to develop guidelines for judges. This legacy continues today as Pauline Newman's appeal raises concerns about age and competency, echoing the South Carolina Supreme Court's suspension of Judge Darrell Scott Fisher for misconduct, highlighting ongoing issues in judicial accountability.

1 of 3

Newman Appeals Suspension

Pauline Newman, a 98-year-old federal judge, is appealing to the Supreme Court to restore her position after a three-year suspension due to competency concerns, despite not being found incompetent.
The Supreme Court's decision to hear her case remains uncertain, as it accepts few cases.
Separately, the South Carolina Supreme Court suspended Judge Darrell Scott Fisher for 30 days for improper communication in a restraining order case, where he admitted wrongdoing.
Fisher plans to retire in 2026, underscoring ongoing discussions about judicial conduct and age in the legal system.

1 / 3