Story perspectives
Public Inquiry Launched into Emma Caldwell Murder Case Handling
4/6/2026
1 of 1
Story summary
- Iain Packer was convicted in 2024 of Emma Caldwell's murder and related sexual offenses.
- Former detectives Davie Barr and Stuart Hall say they were certain of Packer's guilt.
- Barr recalls being told to dismiss concerns.
- A public inquiry led by Lord Scott KC will investigate how the police handled Caldwell's case.
- Police Scotland has committed to supporting the inquiry.
