Redistricting Reform Sparks GOP Primary Challenge for Rep. Blake Moore

Republican Representative Blake Moore's past support for a redistricting reform initiative is now fueling a contentious primary challenge in Utah. Moore, who co-chaired the successful 2018 anti-gerrymandering Proposition 4, is facing backlash from within his party as a result of a court-ordered congressional map that has created a new safe Democratic seat in Salt Lake City. This development has led to significant frustration among Utah Republicans, who are now questioning Moore's political future.

Politico

Moore's political ascent began with his involvement in the Better Boundaries initiative, which aimed to limit gerrymandering in Utah. The passage of Proposition 4 established an independent redistricting advisory commission, a move that was initially celebrated. However, a ruling by District Judge Dianna Gibson last year determined that the state legislature had failed to comply with the initiative, resulting in a map that included a Democratic-leaning district. This ruling has since prompted Republican efforts to repeal Proposition 4, although attempts to place a repeal vote on the ballot have faltered.

Politico

Moore's primary challenger, former state Representative Karianne Lisonbee, has criticized him for his role in creating the new Democratic seat, dubbing him "Salt Lake Blake." Utah House Speaker Mike Schultz has endorsed Lisonbee, branding Moore as "not a conservative." Additionally, Sen. Mike Lee's adviser has publicly attacked Moore, suggesting that his leadership has contributed to the current political landscape.

Politico

The backlash against Moore is not limited to his opponents. Some within the Republican Party have expressed disappointment in his response to the redistricting situation. Utah GOP Chair Rob Axson has indicated that Better Boundaries has shifted from its original mission, aligning with left-leaning groups. Critics argue that Moore should take a stronger stance against the consequences of the court's ruling, with some suggesting that his failure to do so is fostering resentment among party members.

Politico

In response to the criticism, Moore has maintained that his original goal was fair representation, not the creation of a Democratic seat. He has expressed disapproval of the judge's ruling and has distanced himself from the repeal efforts, stating that he would have preferred a constitutional amendment. Despite the challenges, Moore remains confident in his political future, emphasizing his leadership role and support from various Utah politicians.

Politico

As the primary election approaches, Moore's internal polling suggests he holds a significant lead over Lisonbee and another challenger, Colton Hatch. However, the upcoming state Republican Party convention on April 25 could prove pivotal, as hardliners have historically dominated the event. The outcome of this primary may have lasting implications for Moore's aspirations for higher office, including potential runs for governor or U.S. Senate in 2028.

Politico

• “To a lot of the Republicans who have served for a long time and have been in leadership, like me, Prop 4 is a slap in the face,” — Don Guymon, Chair of the Davis County GOP

Politico

• “Salt Lake Blake planned for this mess all along,” — Dan Hauser, Chief Strategist for Sen. Mike Lee

Politico

• “I don’t think [this year] is any different. It’s always just another thing, opportunistic thing, to try to pin on me.” — Rep. Blake Moore

Politico

• “There’s no way Blake would win the Republican primary [for governor] after costing Utah a Republican seat in Congress,” — Mike Schultz, Utah House Speaker

Politico

The evolving dynamics surrounding redistricting in Utah illustrate the complexities of intra-party politics and the potential consequences for elected officials who champion reform initiatives.

Politico