Full Breakdown
Netflix's "Big Mistakes": A Chaotic Crime Comedy
4/9/2026, 1:29:20 PM
Overview of the Series
"Big Mistakes," a new crime comedy series on Netflix, is co-created by Dan Levy and Rachel Sennott. The show follows siblings Nicky (Levy) and Morgan (Taylor Ortega) as they navigate a chaotic world of crime after a seemingly innocent act of shoplifting spirals into a dangerous entanglement with organized crime. Set in New Jersey, the narrative begins with the siblings tasked to buy a birthday gift for their dying grandmother, leading to a series of increasingly absurd events.
Core Narrative: Siblings Entangled in Crime
The plot kicks off when Morgan steals a necklace from a local store, which inadvertently draws them into the orbit of a Russian gangster named Ivan (Mark Ivanir). As they become embroiled in criminal activities, the siblings must balance their personal lives—Nicky's secret relationship with contractor Tareq (Jacob Gutierrez) and Morgan's tumultuous engagement with Max (Jack Innanen)—with the demands of their new criminal roles. The series explores themes of family dynamics, ambition, and the absurdity of their circumstances.
Character Dynamics and Performances
The chemistry between Levy and Ortega is a highlight of the series, showcasing their sibling rivalry and comedic timing. Critics note that while Nicky is portrayed as a conflicted pastor hiding his sexuality, Morgan's character is more defined, often leading to humorous confrontations. Laurie Metcalf's portrayal of their mother, Linda, who is simultaneously managing a mayoral campaign, adds another layer of chaos to the family dynamic. Critics praise Metcalf's performance as a manic yet relatable character, contributing significantly to the show's comedic tone.
Criticism of the Narrative Structure
Despite the strong performances, the narrative has faced criticism for its convoluted plot and lack of depth. Reviewers argue that the storyline often requires a suspension of disbelief, with some episodes feeling disjointed or lacking coherence. The chaotic nature of the plot, while entertaining, sometimes detracts from character development and emotional resonance. Critics suggest that sharper writing could enhance the comedic elements and provide a more cohesive viewing experience.
Official Statements & Responses
Critics have noted that "Big Mistakes" is not aiming to replicate the warmth of Levy's previous work, "Schitt's Creek," but instead embraces a more frenetic and chaotic style. The show has been described as a blend of humor and absurdity, with moments that resonate with real-life struggles, such as Morgan's commitment issues and Nicky's secretive lifestyle as a pastor.
What's Next: Potential for Season Two
The season finale leaves viewers with a significant cliffhanger, revealing that Annette (Elizabeth Perkins), Max's mother, is the true mastermind behind the criminal activities. This twist sets the stage for potential future developments in a second season, as Nicky and Morgan find themselves further entangled in Annette's schemes. The series concludes with a sense of unresolved tension, suggesting that their chaotic journey is far from over.
Conclusion
"Big Mistakes" is a wild ride that combines humor with the absurdities of crime and family life. While the narrative may falter at times, the performances and comedic energy keep viewers engaged. As the series is now streaming on Netflix, it has the potential to become a standout comedy, inviting audiences to explore the chaotic lives of its characters further in a possible second season.
