Full Breakdown
Smithtown Council Member Charged with Assault After Physical Altercation
4/9/2026, 10:22:40 PM
Incident Overview: Assault During Closed-Door Meeting
On April 4, 2026, during a closed-door executive session of the Smithtown Town Board, a physical altercation erupted between council members Thomas Lohmann and Tom McCarthy. Lohmann, 68, allegedly assaulted McCarthy, also 68, after a heated argument regarding an undisclosed legal matter. Witnesses reported that Lohmann rushed at McCarthy, who was seated four chairs away, and punched him multiple times. The incident occurred in the presence of the town supervisor, town attorney, and other board members.
Background: Political Tensions
Thomas Lohmann, a former NYPD homicide detective, has served on the Smithtown Town Council since 2018. His political rivalry with Tom McCarthy dates back to 2017 when McCarthy defeated Lohmann in a Republican primary for the town council. This history of competition may have contributed to the tensions that escalated into violence during the recent meeting.
Consequences of the Altercation
Following the incident, McCarthy expressed concerns for his safety, stating that he no longer feels secure working alongside Lohmann. He is now seeking a restraining order against Lohmann. Reports indicate that McCarthy sustained injuries from the assault, requiring an MRI on four different parts of his body, including his jaw, neck, and shoulder. Lohmann has been charged with assault and is scheduled to appear in court on April 28, 2026.
Official Statements & Responses
In the aftermath of the altercation, McCarthy commented on the incident, emphasizing his fear of working with Lohmann. He stated, “I no longer feel safe,” highlighting the severity of the situation. Lohmann has not publicly responded to the allegations or the charges against him.
Criticism & Opposition
The incident has drawn criticism from various community members and political observers, who are concerned about the implications of such violence among elected officials. The altercation raises questions about the conduct expected from public servants and the potential impact on governance in Smithtown.
Conflicting Reports & Gaps
While multiple sources confirm the details of the altercation, there are discrepancies regarding the exact nature of the legal matter that sparked the argument. Additionally, there is no information available on the perspectives of other board members present during the incident.
What's Next: Legal Proceedings
As the situation unfolds, Lohmann's court appearance on April 28 will be a critical moment in determining the legal consequences of the assault. The outcome may also influence McCarthy's request for a restraining order and the future dynamics within the Smithtown Town Board.
