USS Boise Overhaul Scrapped Amid Rising Costs

The USS Boise, a Los Angeles-class nuclear submarine, is being taken offline after incurring approximately $800 million in overhaul costs, with projections indicating that total maintenance expenses could reach $1.9 billion. This decision comes as Secretary of the Navy John Phelan acknowledged significant miscalculations in the submarine's refurbishment process, stating, "We screwed up." The Navy has opted to scrap the Boise and instead focus on building new submarines as part of President Donald Trump's vision for a "Golden Fleet."

Alternet

The decision to scrap the USS Boise reflects broader financial challenges within the U.S. Navy. The Congressional Budget Office estimates that constructing a modern equivalent of the Boise would cost around $8.7 billion, while the Navy's own calculations suggest a figure closer to $7.1 billion. In contrast, modern aircraft carriers, such as the Gerald R. Ford-class, are reported to cost approximately $13 billion each due to their advanced technology and complexity.

Alternet

Secretary Phelan's remarks indicate a shift towards "radical transparency" in the Navy's operations, emphasizing the need for prudent economic decisions. He stated, “I think, by killing these programs, it’s sending a message that we’re not going to continue to send good money after bad investments.” However, he also expressed concerns that Trump's proposed budget of $65.8 billion for shipbuilding may not suffice to meet the ambitious production goals set for the fleet.

Alternet

President Trump's budget proposal aims to enhance naval capabilities by funding the construction of 18 battle force ships and 16 non-battle vessels, alongside increasing public shipyard capacity. This initiative is part of a broader strategy to modernize the Navy, which Phelan believes is crucial for improving operational readiness. He noted that the 2027 budget would significantly impact the Navy's ability to achieve its production targets.

Alternet

Despite the Navy's efforts to address its financial challenges, critics have raised concerns about the implications of scrapping the USS Boise. Some argue that abandoning the overhaul of existing submarines may lead to a reliance on new constructions that could take years to complete, potentially compromising naval readiness in the interim.

Alternet

While the Navy's estimates for the cost of building new submarines vary, there is a consensus that the financial burden of maintaining older vessels like the USS Boise has become unsustainable. The lack of clarity regarding the adequacy of the proposed budget for shipbuilding further complicates the situation, raising questions about the Navy's future capabilities.

Alternet

• “We did. This doesn’t look good. It is what it is. Time to move on, and try to get going in the future and move forward.” — John Phelan, Secretary of the Navy

Alternet

• “I think, by killing these programs, it’s sending a message that we’re not going to continue to send good money after bad investments, and that we’re going to try to make prudent economic decisions that are in the best interest of the fleet and the force,” — John Phelan, Secretary of the Navy

Alternet

The decision to scrap the USS Boise marks a significant moment in the Navy's ongoing efforts to modernize its fleet while grappling with budgetary constraints and operational readiness.

Alternet