Full Breakdown
Potential Trades for T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith: Analyzing the Pittsburgh Steelers' Offseason Moves
4/11/2026, 3:31:43 AM
Overview of Trade Possibilities
The Pittsburgh Steelers are contemplating significant roster changes this offseason, particularly concerning their outside linebacker position. With T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith leading a talented group of edge rushers, the team faces a dilemma regarding playing time and potential trades. Reports suggest that the Steelers may consider trading either Watt or Highsmith, with various factors influencing their decision.
Trade Value and Market Dynamics
T.J. Watt, a two-time NFL Defensive Player of the Year, is a key figure in this discussion. At 31 years old, his age may impact his trade value. Comparisons have been drawn to recent trades involving younger edge rushers, such as Micah Parsons, who was traded for two first-round picks. However, analysts predict that Watt's trade value would likely be limited to a future second-round pick due to his age and the substantial salary remaining on his contract.
In contrast, Alex Highsmith, who is under 30 and has a more affordable contract, could attract a second-round pick as well. Highsmith's performance in 2025, where he recorded 9.5 sacks, positions him as a desirable asset for teams looking to bolster their pass rush.
Potential Trade Partners
If the Steelers decide to move forward with a trade, several teams could emerge as potential partners. The Jacksonville Jaguars and Indianapolis Colts are identified as teams in need of improved pass-rush capabilities. Additionally, the Detroit Lions have shown interest in Highsmith, viewing him as a cost-effective option to enhance their defensive lineup.
Official Statements & Responses
Gerry Dulac, a Pittsburgh Steelers insider, indicated that the team might consider trading a player ahead of Nick Herbig on the depth chart, hinting at Watt or Highsmith as candidates. He noted, "Chances are, the Steelers could get a second-round pick for Highsmith," emphasizing the potential for a trade to occur after the NFL Draft.
Criticism & Opposition
Despite the potential benefits of trading either player, some analysts express skepticism about the wisdom of such moves. Critics argue that trading Watt, a franchise cornerstone, could undermine the team's competitive edge. The Steelers' history of quarterback instability has also led to frustration among fans, who may view trading key defensive players as a step backward.
What's Next
As the offseason progresses, the Steelers will need to weigh their options carefully. With the NFL Draft approaching, the organization must decide whether to retain their star linebackers or explore trades that could reshape their roster for the future. The outcome of these deliberations will significantly impact the team's strategy moving forward.
Verbatim Quotes
- “Alex Highsmith's Trade Price Chances are, the Steelers could get a second-round pick for Highsmith.” — Gerry Dulac, Pittsburgh Steelers Insider
- “If the Steelers do move Watt or Highsmith, it's hard to see it happening during the NFL Draft.” — Analyst Commentary
In conclusion, the Pittsburgh Steelers face critical decisions regarding T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith that could define their offseason strategy and future competitiveness in the NFL.
