Criticism of Brig. Gen. Gal Hirsch's Selection Sparks Controversy Among Hostage Families

Rom Braslavski, a former hostage of Hamas, has faced significant backlash after publicly criticizing the selection of Brig. Gen. (res.) Gal Hirsch to light a torch at the Independence Day ceremony on Mount Herzl. Braslavski described this choice as “a slap in the face” to himself and other families of hostages and murder victims, asserting that Hirsch is “only playing politics” and failed to reach out to him after his release.

The Jerusalem Post

The decision to appoint Gal Hirsch for this ceremonial role has been contentious, particularly among those directly affected by the hostage crisis. Braslavski's remarks reflect a broader sentiment among families of hostages and victims, who feel that their experiences and suffering are being overlooked in favor of political gestures.

The Jerusalem Post

Following his criticism, Braslavski became the target of a wave of online abuse from right-wing social media users. He reported receiving numerous derogatory messages, including accusations of ingratitude and suggestions that he should be thankful for his return. Critics questioned his right to voice dissent against Hirsch's selection, emphasizing a narrative that frames his criticism as ungratefulness.

The Jerusalem Post

Amidst the online vitriol, Braslavski shared a moment of kindness on social media, where he recounted buying cold drinks for older Arab workers laboring in the heat. He expressed surprise at their reaction to his gesture, noting that his actions were intended to transcend the animosity stemming from his past experiences. Braslavski stated, “I don’t understand why helping someone else has become something unusual,” emphasizing his commitment to maintaining humanity despite his traumatic experiences.

The Jerusalem Post

The backlash against Braslavski highlights a divide within the community regarding the appropriateness of Hirsch's selection. Many families of hostages and victims have echoed Braslavski's sentiments, feeling that the choice of Hirsch does not honor their struggles. This dissent underscores a broader conversation about the representation of trauma and the political implications of public ceremonies.

The Jerusalem Post

While Braslavski's remarks have drawn significant attention, there has been no official response from the organizers of the Independence Day ceremony regarding the backlash or the selection of Hirsch. The silence from official channels may further fuel the discontent among those affected by the hostage crisis.

The Jerusalem Post

• “Braslavski wrote on social media that the choice of Hirsch is “a slap in the face” to him, his parents, and other hostage families.” — Rom Braslavski, Former Hostage

The Jerusalem Post

• “I couldn’t stand seeing older people working like that,” — Rom Braslavski, on helping Arab workers

The Jerusalem Post

• “Why should an older Arab man be shocked that a young Jewish man helps him?” — Rom Braslavski, reflecting on humanity amidst conflict

The Jerusalem Post

The controversy surrounding the selection of Gal Hirsch is likely to continue, as discussions about the representation of trauma and the political dimensions of public ceremonies unfold. The reactions from both the public and the families of hostages may influence future decisions regarding similar events.

The Jerusalem Post