The Evolving Landscape of Private Credit ETFs

Liquidity concerns have emerged as a significant issue for investors in private credit, particularly as these investments are not designed for daily trading like exchange-traded funds (ETFs). Investors seeking to withdraw funds from private credit managers often face restrictions, especially during periods of market stress. In contrast, ETFs offer daily liquidity, allowing investors to sell their holdings, albeit sometimes at a discount to net asset value. For instance, the State Street Global Advisors' BIZD ETF closed at a discount to its net asset value 37 times in 2025 and 12 times in the current year.

CNBC

In response to the liquidity challenges associated with private credit, State Street has developed private credit ETFs in collaboration with Apollo Global Management. The State Street IG Public & Private Credit ETF (PRIV) was the first private credit-branded ETF approved by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in February 2025. Following this, the State Street Short Duration IG Public & Private Credit ETF (PRSD) was launched later that same year. These funds aim to outperform traditional bond benchmarks by incorporating investment-grade private credit, with the flexibility to allocate between 10% and 35% in private credit issues.

CNBC

Despite their focus on private credit, the current holdings of these ETFs reveal a predominance of more traditional assets. For example, only one of PRIV's top ten holdings is in private credit, while treasury and mortgage-backed securities make up the majority. Similarly, PRSD's holdings consist of a mix of government, mortgage, and currency securities. This composition raises questions about the extent to which these ETFs can deliver on their promise to provide exposure to private credit.

CNBC

Industry experts emphasize the importance of managing liquidity risks in private credit investments. "You're gating because you said we can't have a run on the bank," noted a market analyst, highlighting the necessity of limiting withdrawals to prevent forced selling and maintain stability. The introduction of private credit ETFs is seen as a strategic move to enhance access to this asset class while addressing liquidity concerns.

CNBC

Critics argue that while private credit ETFs may provide some level of liquidity, they do not fully mitigate the inherent risks associated with private credit investments. Concerns remain regarding the potential for forced selling during market downturns and the overall stability of these funds in times of financial stress.

CNBC

As the market for private credit ETFs continues to evolve, investors and analysts will be closely monitoring their performance and liquidity characteristics. The ongoing development of these financial products may reshape the landscape of fixed-income investing, particularly as more investors seek alternatives to traditional bond markets.

CNBC