Story perspectives

Election Tie in Wisconsin Resolved by Coin Flip

4/13/2026

Summary

Story summary

In Hortonville, Wisconsin, a local election ended in a tie, with Dalton Davis and Shauna Keel each receiving 356 votes for the final trustee position.
The Village Board of Canvassers resolved the tie using State Statute 5.01(4), resulting in Davis winning after the coin landed on tails.
Davis, who had voted for Keel, expressed disappointment but stated there were no hard feelings.
The state GOP faces internal pressure for leadership changes after a significant defeat in the recent Supreme Court race, raising concerns about fundraising and messaging.

History

Historical Context

In 1974, Wisconsin enacted State Statute 5.01(4) to resolve election ties through random methods, enhancing electoral integrity. This law gained attention when Dalton Davis and Shauna Keel tied with 356 votes in a recent election. Such measures reflect ongoing challenges in electoral fairness, particularly as the state GOP faces difficulties following a Supreme Court defeat, underscoring the need for clear electoral laws.

1 of 2

Story summary

In Hortonville, Wisconsin, a local election ended in a tie, with Dalton Davis and Shauna Keel each receiving 356 votes for the final trustee position.
The Village Board of Canvassers resolved the tie using State Statute 5.01(4), resulting in Davis winning after the coin landed on tails.
Davis, who had voted for Keel, expressed disappointment but stated there were no hard feelings.
The state GOP faces internal pressure for leadership changes after a significant defeat in the recent Supreme Court race, raising concerns about fundraising and messaging.

1 / 2