Trump's Third-Country Deportation Strategy Faces Challenges

In the first year of President Donald Trump’s second term, the administration has intensified its efforts to deport undocumented immigrants, expelling over 675,000 individuals. Despite this, the goal of achieving one million deportations annually remains unmet. A significant aspect of this strategy involves negotiating agreements with various countries to accept deportees, even if they are not citizens of those nations. However, the effectiveness of this approach has been called into question.

CNNNew York TimesNew York TimesPeople MagazineThe BulwarkCBS News

Stephen Miller, a key architect of Trump's immigration policy, has spearheaded efforts to establish third-country removal agreements. These arrangements aim to facilitate the deportation of individuals whose home countries refuse to accept them. Countries such as El Salvador, Panama, Costa Rica, and Uzbekistan have reportedly accepted a limited number of deportees, while Mexico remains the primary destination, having accepted approximately 13,000 non-Mexican nationals in the past year.

CNNNew York TimesNew York TimesThe BulwarkPeople MagazineCBS News

The administration's strategy serves dual purposes: bypassing uncooperative countries and deterring potential migrants by threatening deportation to unfamiliar nations. However, the actual number of deportations to third countries has been minimal, with estimates suggesting only about 15,000 individuals were sent to such locations in 2025.

CNN

White House spokeswoman Abigail Jackson emphasized that the administration is utilizing all available resources to execute what it describes as the largest lawful deportation operation in history. The State Department has reiterated that implementing Trump’s immigration policies is a top priority. However, internal frustrations have surfaced, particularly from Miller, who expressed dissatisfaction with the slow pace of deportations to third countries during a recent multiagency call.

CNN

Critics argue that the administration's aggressive deportation strategy disproportionately targets vulnerable populations and fails to address the complexities of international relations. The Migration Policy Institute has noted that many countries involved in agreements have not publicly accepted any deportees, raising concerns about the efficacy of these arrangements. Additionally, legal challenges have emerged against the deportation of individuals to countries where they may face danger or persecution.

CNN

While some sources indicate that the administration has successfully negotiated agreements with multiple countries, others highlight that many of these nations have not accepted any deportees. The Democratic Republic of Congo, for instance, recently announced an agreement with the U.S., yet it remains unclear if any deportations have occurred under this arrangement.

CNN

• “The Trump Administration is using all the tools in our toolbox to carry out the largest, lawful deportation operation of criminal illegal aliens in history,” — Abigail Jackson, White House Spokeswoman

CNN

• “We are working with other countries to say, ‘We want to send you some of the most despicable human beings to your countries — will you do that as a favor to us?’ And the further away from America, the better, so they can’t come back across the border,” — Marco Rubio, Secretary of State

CNN

The Trump administration's strategy of deporting undocumented immigrants to third countries has faced significant hurdles, including limited cooperation from foreign governments and legal challenges. As the administration continues to pursue its aggressive immigration agenda, the effectiveness and humanitarian implications of these policies remain subjects of intense scrutiny and debate.

CNN