Morrissey Challenges Johnny Marr's Account of The Smiths' History

Morrissey has publicly contested Johnny Marr's recent comments regarding the signing of The Smiths to Rough Trade Records in 1983. This dispute arises as Rough Trade celebrates its 50th anniversary, during which Marr reportedly provided an account to The Guardian about how he and bassist Andy Rourke delivered the band's demo to the label. Morrissey asserts that this narrative is "deliberately untrue," claiming that he and Marr were the ones who made the journey to Rough Trade, while Rourke had not yet committed to the band. Morrissey expressed his belief that Marr is aware of this distortion but has nonetheless allowed it to be published.

Morrissey Calls Johnny Marr’s Rough Trade Narrative “Deliberately Untrue”NME | New Musical Express

The Smiths signed with Rough Trade after initially being rejected by Factory Records and EMI. They presented a demo tape featuring "Hand in Glove" and a live version of "Handsome Devil" to Rough Trade's founder. The band was signed to a one-single deal, releasing "Hand in Glove" in May 1983, followed by a broader contract later that year.

NME | New Musical Express

In addition to contesting Marr's narrative, Morrissey has also claimed sole responsibility for the iconic photograph of The Smiths taken outside Salford Lads Club in December 1985. He stated that the idea for the photo was his alone, contrary to claims that it was a collective decision by the band. This photograph has become a significant cultural symbol, attracting fans who recreate the image at the location.

NME | New Musical ExpressMorrissey Calls Johnny Marr’s Rough Trade Narrative “Deliberately Untrue”

Morrissey criticized the portrayal of his role in The Smiths' history, stating that he was mentioned only as a footnote in Marr's account. He emphasized that "true will always be true, despite the efforts of Marr and his Guardian to shift the narrative." He also noted that both Rough Trade and Warner Records assured him that the article featuring Marr's comments would not be published.

Morrissey Calls Johnny Marr’s Rough Trade Narrative “Deliberately Untrue”

While Morrissey has been vocal about his disagreements with Marr, there has been no immediate response from Marr's management regarding these latest claims. However, previous statements from Marr have refuted Morrissey's assertions about their past interactions, including the alleged blocking of Smiths reissues and a proposed reunion tour.

NME | New Musical Express

There are discrepancies in the accounts of The Smiths' signing with Rough Trade, particularly regarding who was involved in delivering the demo. Morrissey's claims directly contradict Marr's narrative, highlighting a long-standing tension between the two former bandmates. Additionally, the status of the rumored article in The Guardian remains uncertain, as it has not been published.

Morrissey Calls Johnny Marr’s Rough Trade Narrative “Deliberately Untrue”

• “Naturally, this is deliberately untrue.” — Morrissey

Morrissey Calls Johnny Marr’s Rough Trade Narrative “Deliberately Untrue”

• “If I had suggested a photo outside Kellogg’s the likelihood is that the other three would have done that instead.” — Morrissey

NME | New Musical Express

• “Marr must be fully aware of this distortion, but he nonetheless approved the text which, being written by a Guardian-stasi functionary, mentioned Morrissey only as a footnote in the Smiths history, and not as a founding member who solely created the group name,” — Morrissey

NME | New Musical Express

• “I didn’t ignore the offer – I said no.” — Johnny Marr

NME | New Musical Express

This ongoing dispute reflects the complex relationship between Morrissey and Marr, as both continue to navigate their shared history while addressing their individual narratives in the public eye.

Morrissey Calls Johnny Marr’s Rough Trade Narrative “Deliberately Untrue”