Cody Rhodes Faces Backlash Over WrestleMania Picks

Cody Rhodes, a prominent figure in professional wrestling, recently sparked significant criticism from fans during an appearance on ESPN's "First Take." When asked by host Courtney Cronin to name his top five WrestleMania wrestlers of all time, Rhodes included current stars and legends but notably omitted The Undertaker, a decision that led to widespread backlash. His list featured Charlotte Flair in fifth place, followed by Randy Savage, Shawn Michaels, Roman Reigns, and Hulk Hogan at the top.

Newsweek

The absence of The Undertaker, who is renowned for his legendary 21-0 streak at WrestleMania, did not sit well with many fans. Comments on social media reflected a strong sentiment that Rhodes' list was invalid without including The Undertaker and John Cena. One fan remarked, "But no Undertaker?? No Cena?? Yeah … the replies about to be chaotic," while another stated, "Everyone has their opinion which is totally understandable but not including Undertaker and John Cena should be a criminal offense." Some speculated that Rhodes' choices were influenced by current WWE narratives, suggesting that including Flair and Reigns was a public relations move ahead of WrestleMania 42, where both are scheduled to compete.

Newsweek

WrestleMania 42 is set to take place soon, with Charlotte Flair participating in a Fatal Four-Way match for the WWE Women's Tag Team Championship alongside Alexa Bliss, The Bella Twins, and current champions Lash Legend and Nia Jax. Roman Reigns is also slated for a main event match against CM Punk for the World Heavyweight Championship, marking another significant moment in his illustrious career. The timing of Rhodes' comments has led some to believe that his selections were strategically aligned with promoting the upcoming event.

Newsweek

While Rhodes has not publicly addressed the backlash, the criticism highlights the passionate nature of wrestling fandom and the expectations surrounding discussions of wrestling history. The reactions underscore the importance of The Undertaker's legacy in the WWE universe, particularly in the context of WrestleMania.

Newsweek

There is a notable gap in understanding whether Rhodes would have included other iconic wrestlers, such as Stone Cold Steve Austin or The Rock, had he been asked to name a broader list of top WrestleMania wrestlers. The lack of clarity on this point leaves fans speculating about his criteria for selection.

Newsweek

• “But no Undertaker?? No Cena?? Yeah … the replies about to be chaotic,” — Fan Comment

Newsweek

• “I don’t care if it’s his opinion, no undertaker makes the list invalid,” — Fan Comment

Newsweek

• “Having Charlotte and Roman on there was clearly a PR move.” — Fan Comment

Newsweek

Cody Rhodes' WrestleMania picks have ignited a debate among fans, reflecting the deep connections and expectations that wrestling enthusiasts have regarding the sport's history and its icons.

Newsweek