Full Breakdown
Cincinnati Police Chief Teresa Theetge Faces Leadership Investigation
4/15/2026, 3:02:50 PM
Overview of the Investigation
The City of Cincinnati has engaged the employment law firm Jackson Lewis P.C. to assist in reviewing the leadership of Cincinnati Police Chief Teresa Theetge, who has been on paid administrative leave since October. This decision follows a pre-disciplinary hearing involving Theetge and City Manager Sheryl Long, as the city evaluates the findings of an independent investigation conducted by Frost Brown Todd. The investigation's summary, released in March, concluded that Theetge had "not been an effective leader," citing issues such as a "siloing of departments" and a communication style that fostered "lack of transparency and distrust" within the Cincinnati Police Department (CPD).
Findings of the Independent Investigation
The nine-page report from Frost Brown Todd was based on interviews with 32 witnesses and criticized Theetge's leadership approach, stating that it led to competition among departments for resources and information. The report indicated that most witnesses believed she could not effectively return to the CPD. Additionally, it highlighted a culture of retaliation and perceptions of favoritism within the department. Theetge's attorneys have labeled the investigation as "hasty and unlawful," arguing that it serves as a "political scapegoat" ahead of upcoming elections.
Official Statements & Responses
Following the pre-disciplinary hearing, Theetge's attorney, Stephen Imm, expressed hope that the city would recognize the lack of merit in the allegations against her. He stated, "I can tell you that there is nothing left of the allegations made against Chief Theetge after what we heard today." Theetge herself commented on the support she has received from the community, stating, "I can't go anywhere in this region without somebody stopping me and saying, 'I've been treated badly by the city.'" Imm further noted that any decision to remove Theetge would lead to significant repercussions, asserting, "There's no amount of money that could ever restore the reputation that Chief Theetge has lost."
Criticism of the Investigation
Theetge's family and supporters have criticized the investigation's findings, with her brother, retired Cincinnati Police Captain Russ Neville, claiming the report lacks credibility and does not reflect a true investigative process. He described it as biased and speculative, asserting that it was designed to undermine Theetge's position.
What's Next for Theetge
As the city continues its review of Theetge's employment status, the outcome remains uncertain. Theetge has expressed her desire to return to her role, stating, “I miss the work. I miss the men and women of CPD immensely.” The decision by the city will not only impact Theetge's career but could also have broader implications for the Cincinnati Police Department and its leadership structure.
