Rising Costs of Affordable Care Act Plans Lead to Increased Uninsured Rates

In 2026, rising health insurance costs under the Affordable Care Act (ACA) have resulted in a significant number of enrollees failing to pay their premiums, leading to concerns about increased uninsured rates. According to a report from Wakely Consulting Group, approximately 14% of individuals who enrolled in ACA plans did not pay their first monthly premium, a notable increase from the typical early-year drop-off of around 5%. This trend is attributed to the expiration of enhanced federal subsidies that were previously available during the COVID-19 pandemic.

HealthCareDive14% of ACA enrollees did not pay premiums in January: Report

The expiration of these subsidies has led to substantial premium increases, with some enrollees experiencing hikes of over 400%. For instance, Sarah Smith, a 53-year-old office manager from Ohio, saw her premium rise from $150 to approximately $700, prompting her to switch to a less comprehensive short-term policy. Similarly, Sharon Dunham, a 63-year-old cancer survivor, faced a premium increase from $614 to nearly $980. Experts warn that such increases could disproportionately affect younger and healthier individuals, who are more likely to drop coverage, thereby leaving a sicker population in the ACA exchanges.

UsNews and World Report

Wakely's analysis predicts that overall ACA enrollment could decline by 17% to 26% in 2026, with some states experiencing even higher losses. For example, Blue Cross Blue Shield in Arizona reported a 30% drop in enrollees due to non-payment. The analysis indicates that those who did pay their premiums in January were, on average, 10% less healthy than those who did not, suggesting a concerning trend toward a less healthy insured population.

HealthCareDive

Health policy experts have expressed alarm over the potential implications of these trends. Michael Cohen, co-author of the Wakely report, emphasized the uncertainty surrounding the ability of insurers to adjust to these changes, stating, "These findings highlight a level of uncertainty that issuers and policymakers will need to carefully navigate." The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) reported a smaller overall enrollment drop of about 5%, but this figure does not account for those who have not effectuated their coverage by paying premiums.

HealthCareDive

Critics argue that the expiration of enhanced subsidies has left millions of Americans vulnerable. Democrats attempted to extend these subsidies during negotiations to end a government shutdown, but their efforts were unsuccessful. The Congressional Budget Office has projected that benchmark premiums could rise by 4.3% in 2026 and 7.7% in 2027 without an extension of the subsidies.

14% of ACA enrollees did not pay premiums in January: Report

While Wakely's estimates suggest a significant decline in enrollment, other reports indicate that the actual drop may be less severe than initially feared. The CMS's reported enrollment figures do not reflect the reality of those who are unable to pay premiums, highlighting a gap in understanding the true impact of rising costs on ACA coverage.

HealthCareDive

As the year progresses, the health insurance market will continue to face challenges related to premium pricing and enrollment stability. Insurers will need to monitor claims and utilization closely to determine if premium increases are sufficient to cover the rising morbidity among enrollees. The outcome of ongoing legislative discussions regarding subsidy extensions will also play a critical role in shaping the future of ACA coverage.

HealthCareDive