New Voices in Hawkins: The Animated Spin-Off "Stranger Things: Tales from '85"

"Stranger Things: Tales from '85," an animated series set between seasons 2 and 3 of the original "Stranger Things," is set to premiere on Netflix on April 23, 2024. The series will feature a completely new voice cast, including Brooklyn Davey Norstedt as Eleven, Luca Diaz as Mike Wheeler, and Ben Plessala as Will Byers. This decision to recast the characters has sparked discussions among fans and critics alike.

Radio Times

Showrunner Eric Robles explained that the choice to use new actors was driven by the desire to maintain the authenticity of the characters' ages. He noted that the original cast, now in their twenties, would not convincingly portray the youthful voices of their characters, who are meant to be around 13 to 14 years old during the timeline of the spin-off. Robles emphasized the importance of capturing the "innocence of kids being kids," stating, "Bringing in anybody from the original cast, you're now talking about older voices... We wanted to capture the youthfulness."

Radio Times

Robles highlighted the emotional depth brought by the new voice actors, who were able to deliver performances that resonate with the show's themes. He remarked, "They might be young, but they emote these beautiful performances within the show." The casting process involved reviewing thousands of audition tapes to find actors who could authentically represent the characters' youthful energy.

Radio Times

Despite the rationale provided, some critics have questioned the necessity of recasting. Articles from TechRadar pointed out that the age differences between the new voice actors and the original cast are not as significant as suggested. For instance, Ben Plessala, who voices Will, is only two years younger than Noah Schnapp, the original actor. Critics argue that the decision may have been influenced by financial considerations or the original cast's availability.

TechRadar

While Robles maintains that the new cast brings a fresh perspective to the characters, some fans express disappointment over the absence of the original actors. The debate continues regarding whether the new voices will resonate with audiences familiar with the original series.

Radio Times

As "Stranger Things: Tales from '85" prepares for its debut, the Duffer Brothers have indicated plans for multiple seasons, suggesting that viewers will need to adjust to the new voice cast as the franchise expands. The series aims to explore new narratives while retaining the essence of the beloved original.

'Stranger Things' Star Officially Reveals His Real Thoughts on Eleven's Season 5 Fate

• “ He added: "We wanted to capture the innocence of kids being kids.” — Eric Robles, Showrunner

Radio Times

• “Watch trailer "They might be young, but they emote these beautiful performances within the show, and we're able to capture that, and we actually captured the reality of their emotions," Robles added.” — Eric Robles, Showrunner

Radio Times

• “Imagine you have a 20-something-year-old actor and an animated pre-teen character,” — Eric Robles, Showrunner

TechRadar

The animated series promises to deliver new adventures in Hawkins, even as it navigates the challenges of recasting iconic characters.

Radio Times