Story perspectives

Bishops Rebuke VP Vance Over Pope's War Theory

4/18/2026

Summary

Story summary

Bishops criticized Vice President Jonathan David Vance for challenging Pope Leo XIV on just war theory.
Bishop James Massa said Church teaching, with centuries of doctrine, holds war is justified only in self-defense after peace efforts fail.
Vance, a recent Catholic convert, suggested the pope misinterpreted theology at a Turning Point USA event.
The dispute shows tensions within the Trump administration over Iran war justification, with Vance's remarks drawing backlash.

History

Historical Context

The Fourth Lateran Council in 1215, led by Pope Innocent III, established key doctrines on just war, emphasizing self-defense and peace efforts. This doctrine, rooted in the teachings of Saint Augustine and later developed by thinkers like Thomas Aquinas, continues to influence contemporary military ethics. Recent tensions within the Trump administration regarding military actions, particularly towards Iran, underscore the ongoing relevance of just war theory in modern discourse.

1 of 2

Story summary

Bishops criticized Vice President Jonathan David Vance for challenging Pope Leo XIV on just war theory.
Bishop James Massa said Church teaching, with centuries of doctrine, holds war is justified only in self-defense after peace efforts fail.
Vance, a recent Catholic convert, suggested the pope misinterpreted theology at a Turning Point USA event.
The dispute shows tensions within the Trump administration over Iran war justification, with Vance's remarks drawing backlash.

1 / 2