Gerrit Cole's Rehabilitation Progress: A Step Towards Return

Gerrit Cole, the New York Yankees' ace, made his first minor league rehabilitation start on April 17, 2026, for Double-A Somerset, marking a significant milestone in his recovery from Tommy John surgery. In this outing, Cole pitched 4 1/3 innings, allowing three runs on three hits, including a two-run homer, while striking out three batters and walking one. He threw 36 of his 44 pitches for strikes, showcasing his ability to command the strike zone effectively.

How Yankees’ Gerrit Cole pitched in first rehab start since Tommy John surgeryYankees ace Gerrit Cole pleased with first rehab outing since Tommy John surgeryAssociated PressESPNAudacy NewsESPNFanSidedESPN

During the game against the Reading Fightin Phils, Cole's fastball reached up to 96 mph, indicating a positive return to form. The outing was particularly notable as it was his first competitive appearance since Game 5 of the 2024 World Series. Cole faced challenges in the second inning after a lengthy delay due to a five-run inning by Somerset, which may have affected his rhythm. However, he rebounded well, retiring the side in the third inning and allowing only a single in the fourth before exiting after recording the first out in the fifth.

How Yankees’ Gerrit Cole pitched in first rehab start since Tommy John surgery

Yankees manager Aaron Boone expressed optimism about Cole's performance, stating, "All in all, a really strong step for him." Boone emphasized the importance of a gradual buildup in Cole's workload, indicating that the pitcher would require several more rehab outings before rejoining the Yankees' rotation. The Yankees are targeting a return for Cole in late May or early June, depending on his progress.

ESPN

While Cole's performance was generally well-received, some analysts caution against overestimating his immediate impact. Given that he is returning from major surgery, there are concerns about whether he can regain his previous form as a perennial Cy Young contender. The Yankees' current rotation has performed admirably in his absence, which raises questions about the necessity of rushing Cole back into a starting role.

CBS Sports

Cole himself reflected on his outing, stating, "Just a lot of strike-throwing and pretty solid delivery overall." He acknowledged the need to manage stress during games and emphasized the importance of recovery between outings. Boone reiterated the team's cautious approach, noting, "We’ll be disciplined to make sure we take the right amount of time."

ESPN

Cole's next rehab start is expected to take place with either Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre or High-A Hudson Valley. The Yankees will continue to monitor his progress closely, utilizing the extended rehab assignment rules available for pitchers recovering from Tommy John surgery. This careful management aims to ensure that Cole is fully prepared for the demands of a major league season upon his return.

ESPN

Gerrit Cole's first rehab start represents a crucial step in his recovery journey, with the Yankees optimistic about his return to the rotation. As he continues to build up his pitch count and regain form, both Cole and the team are focused on a successful reintegration into the lineup, which could significantly bolster the Yankees' pitching staff as they navigate the season ahead.

CBS Sports