Activist's Attempt to Free Crayfish Ends in Controversy

On April 10, 2025, Emma Smart, an activist, entered the Catch at the Old Fish Market in Weymouth and forcibly removed a crayfish from a tank, declaring her intention to liberate it. The restaurant owner, Sean Cooper, reported that the crayfish was thrown into the cold sea, likely resulting in its immediate death due to the drastic change in water temperature. Cooper had kept the crayfish, named Ronnie and Reggie, as pets for educational purposes, allowing visitors, especially children, to learn about marine life.

LADbible

Following the incident, Smart was charged with causing unnecessary suffering to a protected animal, theft, and assault. However, she ultimately pleaded guilty to criminal damage and received an eight-month conditional discharge. Additionally, she was banned from approaching the restaurant for three years. Cooper expressed his desire for a harsher penalty, stating that he wanted "the book thrown" at Smart for her actions.

LADbible

Emma Smart has a history of activism related to the restaurant. In 2022, she attempted to enter the same establishment while renowned broadcaster Sir David Attenborough was dining, intending to deliver a letter. At that time, she described the restaurant as a "symbol of excess and inequality," highlighting the economic struggles faced by the local community in Weymouth, which has some of the lowest average wages in the UK.

LADbible

Sean Cooper emphasized the educational role of the crayfish in his restaurant, noting that they provided a unique opportunity for children to learn about marine life. He lamented the loss of the crayfish, stating, "Crayfish are unusual in these waters," and expressed concern over the impact of Smart's actions on the local ecosystem and community engagement.

LADbible

Critics of Smart's actions argue that her attempt to free the crayfish was misguided and ultimately harmful. The local community has expressed frustration over the incident, particularly given the educational value the restaurant provided. Cooper's sentiments reflect a broader concern about the implications of such activism on local businesses and wildlife.

LADbible

• "Crayfish are unusual in these waters. The local fishermen had caught them, we had taken them into the tank... it's amazing, and so we're able to show that to children and educate them." — Sean Cooper, Owner of Catch at the Old Fish Market

LADbible

• "I wanted the book thrown at her." — Sean Cooper, expressing his desire for a harsher penalty for Emma Smart.

LADbible

This incident highlights the complexities surrounding animal rights activism and its potential consequences on local businesses and ecosystems.

LADbible