Story perspectives

Leaked Memos Reveal Supreme Court's Shadow Docket Shift

4/21/2026

Summary

Roberts Blocks Clean Power

The New York Times obtained leaked memos from six Supreme Court justices revealing the shadow docket's origins.
Chief Justice John Roberts urged swift action blocking President Barack Obama’s 2016 Clean Power Plan despite warnings from liberal justices.
The ruling marked a shift in Court operations, increasing the shadow docket's use in high-stakes cases.
Critics argue this undermines transparency and judicial integrity, while defenders say it enables necessary quick responses.

Summary

Kagan Confronts Breyer

Leaked insights from Mollie Hemingway's upcoming book reveal intense internal conflict among Supreme Court justices after the 2022 Dobbs leak.
The book says Justice Elena Kagan confronted Justice Stephen Breyer, urging him not to expedite dissenting opinions amid threats against conservative justices.
The leak solidified Justice Samuel Alito's draft opinion, a development that benefited conservatives.
The fallout included heightened security for justices amid protests and threats, illustrating polarization over abortion rights.

1 of 2

Roberts Blocks Clean Power

The New York Times obtained leaked memos from six Supreme Court justices revealing the shadow docket's origins.
Chief Justice John Roberts urged swift action blocking President Barack Obama’s 2016 Clean Power Plan despite warnings from liberal justices.
The ruling marked a shift in Court operations, increasing the shadow docket's use in high-stakes cases.
Critics argue this undermines transparency and judicial integrity, while defenders say it enables necessary quick responses.

1 / 2