Full Breakdown
Beaches: A Broadway Musical Adaptation Struggles to Make Waves
4/23/2026, 11:16:31 PM
Overview of the Musical's Journey
"Beaches," a new musical adaptation of Iris Rainer Dart's 1985 novel and the beloved 1988 film starring Bette Midler and Barbara Hershey, opened on April 22, 2026, at the Majestic Theatre in New York City. The production, co-directed by Lonny Price and Matt Cowart, features a book by Dart and Thom Thomas, with music by Mike Stoller and lyrics by Dart. This adaptation has faced significant expectations due to its iconic source material, which centers on the lifelong friendship between Cee Cee Bloom and Bertie White.
Core Narrative: Friendship Amidst Trials
The narrative follows Cee Cee and Bertie, two women from contrasting backgrounds who bond on the Atlantic City boardwalk as children. Their friendship endures through various life challenges, including romantic rivalries and personal tragedies, culminating in Bertie's terminal illness. The musical aims to capture the emotional depth of their relationship, but critics have noted that it often falls short of delivering the expected emotional resonance.
Key Performers and Characters
Jessica Vosk stars as Cee Cee, channeling Midler's spirit while bringing her own interpretation to the role. Kelli Barrett plays Bertie, whose character has been criticized for lacking depth compared to Cee Cee. The younger versions of the characters are portrayed by Zeya Grace and Samantha Schwartz, who have received praise for their performances. Critics have highlighted the disparity in character development between the two leads, with Bertie's storyline feeling underdeveloped.
Musical Score and Lyrics
The score, composed by Mike Stoller, has been described as serviceable but lacking memorable melodies that resonate beyond the moment. Critics have pointed out that while the songs fulfill their narrative function, they do not contribute significantly to character development or emotional depth. The climactic number, "Wind Beneath My Wings," while performed powerfully by Vosk, has been noted to lack the emotional weight that made it iconic in the film.
Criticism and Opposition
Critics have expressed disappointment with the musical's execution, citing a lack of emotional clarity and depth. The book's reliance on clichés and a somewhat superficial treatment of the characters' struggles has led to a perception that the adaptation does not fully honor the source material's emotional legacy. Some reviews have described the production as "washed-up" and "fatally misguided," suggesting that it fails to capture the essence of the original story.
Official Statements & Responses
In response to the mixed reviews, producer Jennifer Maloney-Prezioso emphasized the musical's themes of friendship and kindness, stating, "At its heart, Beaches is about showing up for someone — not perfectly, but consistently." The production has also partnered with Lady Gaga's Born This Way Foundation to promote mental health awareness, aligning with the musical's themes.
What's Next for Beaches
"Beaches" is scheduled to run through September 6, 2026, before embarking on a multi-city national tour. Despite the critical challenges, the production aims to connect with audiences through its exploration of friendship and resilience.
Verbatim Quotes
- “It takes a lot of emotion out of me,” — Jessica Vosk, on her experience performing in Beaches.
- “This is a production that could fit as comfortably in a 500-seat theater and a 3,000-seat barn (a national tour is planned for this fall).” — Critic, on the show's adaptability.
- “The aching second act duet, “The Words I Should Have Said,” is sure to resonate with anyone who has ever felt regret.” — Critic, on the musical's emotional moments.
- “That may be the central issue: Beaches is built to be a tearjerker, but this version doesn't quite gets there.” — Critic, summarizing the show's emotional impact.
