Story perspectives

Comey Indicted Over Instagram Seashell Threat to Trump

4/30/2026

Summary

Story summary

Department case against FBI Director James Comey centers on a 2023 Instagram photo of seashells spelling “86 47” that threatens President Donald Trump.
James Comey was indicted on two felony counts of threatening the president, prompting Todd Blanche to call it unacceptable.
Comey’s lawyers will seek dismissal as selective, while prosecutors must meet the 2023 Supreme Court “true threat” standard, a high bar because James Comey claims no intent to harm.

History

Historical Context

In 1969 the Supreme Court’s decision in Watts v. United States created the “true threat” exception, holding that speech intending intimidation is unprotected. The doctrine was reshaped by the 2023 Counterman v. Colorado ruling, which shifted the test to a subjective standard. Prosecutors now must show that James Comey’s 2023 Instagram post was intended as a true threat to former President Donald Trump.

1 of 2

Story summary

Department case against FBI Director James Comey centers on a 2023 Instagram photo of seashells spelling “86 47” that threatens President Donald Trump.
James Comey was indicted on two felony counts of threatening the president, prompting Todd Blanche to call it unacceptable.
Comey’s lawyers will seek dismissal as selective, while prosecutors must meet the 2023 Supreme Court “true threat” standard, a high bar because James Comey claims no intent to harm.

1 / 2