Story perspectives

Court OKs First Choice’s First Amendment Challenge to NJ Subpoena

4/30/2026

Summary

Story summary

The Court allowed First Choice Women’s Resource Centers to pursue its First Amendment suit against Attorney General Matthew Platkin’s subpoena.
The subpoena demanded names and doctors as records in a probe over alleged abortion deception.
Lower courts dismissed the suit, ruling the claims could proceed in state court before any contempt threat.
Republican attorneys general and free-speech groups backed First Choice while Democratic attorneys general and groups defended New Jersey.

History

Historical Context

Roe v. Wade, decided Jan 22 1973 by a 7-2 Supreme Court majority authored by Justice Harry Blackmun, declared a Fourteenth-Amendment privacy right and nullified bans in 30 states. The ruling was upheld in Casey (1992) and overturned by Dobbs (2022). Today, First Choice Women’s Resource Centers contests New Jersey Attorney General Matthew Platkin’s subpoena, invoking Roe’s legacy to protect reproductive-health providers.

1 of 2

Story summary

The Court allowed First Choice Women’s Resource Centers to pursue its First Amendment suit against Attorney General Matthew Platkin’s subpoena.
The subpoena demanded names and doctors as records in a probe over alleged abortion deception.
Lower courts dismissed the suit, ruling the claims could proceed in state court before any contempt threat.
Republican attorneys general and free-speech groups backed First Choice while Democratic attorneys general and groups defended New Jersey.

1 / 2