Story perspectives

Judge Unseals Alleged Epstein Note, Authenticity Remains Unclear

5/10/2026

43 9

Summary

Story summary

District Judge Kenneth Karas unsealed a note alleged to be by Jeffrey Epstein that Nicholas Tartaglione, Epstein’s former cellmate, said he found in July 2019.
Handwriting experts said the note shares spacing, shapes and punctuation with another note, suggesting authorship but not confirming Epstein wrote it.
The Department of Justice has not authenticated the note, which survivors’ attorneys say creates mystery and distracts from accountability while House Oversight Committee investigates.

History

Historical Context

The 1995 O.J. Simpson murder trial, which concluded in October 1995, spotlighted forensic evidence's power to sway public opinion. Forensic analyst Dr. Henry Lee testified that DNA matched the defendants, and the trial cost $30 million, drawing massive media attention. Similarly, Judge Kenneth Karas unsealed a note claimed by Jeffrey Epstein, while handwriting experts and the Department of Justice evaluate its authenticity under Oversight Committee scrutiny. The parallel underscores how high-profile cases repeatedly hinge on contested evidence, prompting calls for stricter evidentiary standards and transparent investigations.

1 of 2

Story summary

District Judge Kenneth Karas unsealed a note alleged to be by Jeffrey Epstein that Nicholas Tartaglione, Epstein’s former cellmate, said he found in July 2019.
Handwriting experts said the note shares spacing, shapes and punctuation with another note, suggesting authorship but not confirming Epstein wrote it.
The Department of Justice has not authenticated the note, which survivors’ attorneys say creates mystery and distracts from accountability while House Oversight Committee investigates.

1 / 2