Full Breakdown
Blue Jays Scratch Addison Barger from Sunday’s Lineup Over Elbow Soreness
5/10/2026, 10:47:52 PM
Barger Scratched from Sunday’s Lineup
The Toronto Blue Jays confirmed that outfielder Addison Barger will not play in the series-final game against the Los Angeles Angels on May 10, 2026. The decision, announced before the first pitch, cites right elbow soreness. Barger, originally slated to bat lead-off and start in right field, was replaced by infielder Ernie Clement at the top of the order, with Jesus Sánchez moving to right field and Myles Straw taking left field.
Recent Injury History and Return
Barger entered the injured list on April 5 after a left ankle sprain sustained versus the Chicago White Sox. He missed more than a month, was activated on May 9, and returned Saturday. In his first game back, he recorded two walks, a run, and a 101.2 mph throw from right field that threw out Jorge Soler at home plate—the fastest outfield assist recorded for Toronto in the Statcast era.
Data & Statistics
Through nine games in 2026, Barger’s slash line sits at .045/.219/.091 with zero home runs and two RBIs. His 101.2 mph assist is the fastest recorded for the Blue Jays. Toronto entered the Sunday game with an 18-21 record and a 14-1 win over the Angels the previous day, positioning the club for a potential sweep.
Official Statements & Responses
The club issued a pre-game notice stating that Barger was removed from the lineup because of right elbow soreness. Manager John Schneider responded by reshuffling the batting order and defensive alignment, promoting Clement and moving Sánchez and Straw into the outfield. Reporter Keegan Matheson noted that Barger appeared with a large ice wrap on his elbow after Saturday’s game, suggesting a precautionary approach.
Criticism & Opposition
Several fans expressed concern that the scratch reflects a precautionary measure rather than a minor issue. They highlighted the team’s dependence on Barger’s leadoff role and feared a recurring injury could disrupt roster stability as Toronto pursues a sweep.
What’s Next
Toronto will finish the series against the Angels on Sunday and then host the Tampa Bay Rays for a three-game set beginning Monday. The organization indicated that Barger’s elbow will be reassessed after the series, with his availability for the Rays series pending medical clearance.
Verbatim Quotes
- “UPDATE: RF Addison Barger has been removed from today’s lineup with right elbow soreness.” — Toronto Blue Jays (official X announcement)
- “I was pretty happy. It’s so much fun. Throwing the ball from the outfield is one of my favorite parts of the game,” — Addison Barger, outfielder
- “As soon as it left his hand, I knew it was on line,” — Trey Yesavage, pitcher
- “This is prolly more precautionary. We know how important he is to the lineup and we can’t have him hurt again,” — Blue Jays fan (social media)
