Story perspectives

Supreme Court Permits State Lawsuits Over Freight Broker Negligence

5/15/2026

Summary

Story summary

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled that freight brokers can be sued in state courts for negligent hiring of unsafe trucking companies under the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act’s safety exception.
The decision overturns the Seventh and Eleventh Circuits’ broker protections and aligns the law with the Sixth and Ninth Circuits.
Truck safety advocates hailed the ruling as a major win, while industry groups warned of higher insurance costs and consumer prices.

History

Historical Context

The 1994 Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act, signed by President Bill Clinton, carved out a safety exception that preempted 30 state regulations while preserving 13 carrier-related claims, reflecting a post-deregulation shift toward limited federal oversight. Decades after the FAA’s 1958 creation and 1978 airline deregulation, the Supreme Court now extends state-court liability to freight brokers, reshaping trucking compliance.

1 of 2

Story summary

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled that freight brokers can be sued in state courts for negligent hiring of unsafe trucking companies under the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act’s safety exception.
The decision overturns the Seventh and Eleventh Circuits’ broker protections and aligns the law with the Sixth and Ninth Circuits.
Truck safety advocates hailed the ruling as a major win, while industry groups warned of higher insurance costs and consumer prices.

1 / 2