Max Fried’s Elbow Injury Puts Yankees Rotation Under Scrutiny

Max Fried left his May 13 start against the Baltimore Orioles after three innings with left elbow posterior soreness described as a hyperextension. He returned to New York for an MRI and evaluation by team physician Dr. Christopher Ahmad. Early reports suggest the issue may be limited to soft-tissue inflammation, which could allow a return in roughly two to three weeks, pending Thursday’s imaging.

Heavy

The Yankees’ rotation lists left-hander Max Fried, right-hander Gerrit Cole (still recovering from Tommy John surgery), and right-handers Cam Schlittler, Will Warren, Ryan Weathers and Carlos Rodón. Spot-starter options are Elmer Rodríguez and Brendan Beck. Recent IL moves added Giancarlo Stanton (calf), Jasson Domínguez and José Caballero (fractured right middle finger).

New York Post

May 13 – Fried exits after three innings (61 pitches, three runs) as his fastball drops to 88-91 mph early in the game. May 14 – He flies to New York for MRI and physician evaluation. May 15 – MRI scheduled; results pending. Fried’s typical fastball velocity is about 95 mph. Tyler Mahle posted a 2.18 ERA in 16 starts for the Texas Rangers in 2025.

Heavy

Fried’s loss forces the Yankees to rely on spot starters and raises durability concerns. Analysts stress that six healthy starters through October are essential, yet recent injuries and limited depth create doubts. Trade interest in a starter underscores the urgency to maintain a five-day rotation cadence.

The Sporting News

Max Fried said he is “not too worried about a super long-term thing” and hopes to pitch soon. Manager Aaron Boone noted Fried’s “stuff was down” and that it took “two, three hitters in the inning to get to 95 when he needed it.” Dr. Christopher Ahmad said the MRI will confirm whether the injury is limited to soft-tissue inflammation.

Heavy

Analyst Chris Landers urged the Yankees to explore the trade market for a starter, citing durability concerns for several rotation members. He warned that “almost every single one of those players comes with question marks about their durability over the next four-plus months,” and named right-hander Tyler Mahle as a target.

The Sporting News

One source described a “best-case scenario” of a two- to three-week rest if imaging shows only soft-tissue irritation. Another source said Fried’s hope to start his next scheduled game appears “unrealistic” without clean MRI results. The pending scan remains the primary unknown.

Heavy

• “If I can, I’d love to be able to make my next start.” — Max Fried, pitcher

Heavy

• “His stuff was down. It would take him two, three hitters in the inning to get to 95 when he needed it,” — Aaron Boone, manager

Heavy

• “I’m not too worried about a super long-term thing,” — Max Fried, pitcher

Heavy

• “If you waved a magic wand and said that Fried, [Gerrit] Cole, [Carlos] Rodon, [Cam] Schlittler, [Ryan] Weathers, and [Will] Warren would be healthy come the start of October, it would be hard not to feel excited about the Yankees' chances,” — Chris Landers, analyst

The Sporting News