Full Breakdown
Smalley and McNealy Share Lead as Aronimink Produces Bunched PGA Field
5/16/2026, 4:42:15 AM
Midway Leaders at Aronimink
After 36 holes, Alex Smalley (69) and Maverick McNealy (67) are tied at 4-under 136, the highest 36-hole lead since Kiawah Island 2012; the spread from first to last is eight strokes.
First PGA at Aronimink in 64 Years
The PGA returns to Aronimink Golf Club, Pennsylvania, after 64 years; cold, windy mornings and fast, undulating greens produced large, “absurd” pin placements described as the toughest since U.S. Opens and Oakmont.
Main Contenders
Smalley, a five-time top-25 finisher, and McNealy, a former No. 1 amateur, lead a field that includes world No. 1 Scottie Scheffler, Masters champion Rory McIlroy, 2021 Masters champion Hideki Matsuyama, and round-of-the-day Chris Gotterup (65).
Numbers at the Turn
Leaders: Smalley 69, McNealy 67 (4-under). Seven major champions within four shots. 58 players within six shots (Delco Times) vs. 29 within four shots (Sky Sports) – discrepancy. Cut set at 4-over 144; scoring average rose to 73.1.
Why It Matters
The eight-shot spread makes the tournament highly volatile, keeping betting odds fluid and allowing both newcomers and seasoned champions a realistic chance.
Official Statements & Responses
Scheffler called the pins “absurd” and the toughest since U.S. Opens. McIlroy noted the “bunched” leaderboard and praised his driver feel. Gotterup said putts were extremely hard. Matsuyama cited wind-assisted birdies. Smalley called the conditions “difficult.” McNealy expressed surprise at his position and the need to improve his putter.
Criticism & Opposition
Players condemned the “absurd” pin placements and the manufactured green slopes, saying they favored only precise shots and slowed play.
Conflicting Reports & Gaps
Sources differ on how many players are within striking distance (58 within six shots vs. 29 within four) and on the exact count of 2-under competitors.
Verbatim Quotes
- “Anyone who makes the cut, they’ve got to feel they have a shot in the tournament,” — Rory McIlroy, Masters champion
- “A lot of really good moments, some not so great moments, and then a lot of just trying to keep moving forward in between,” — Alex Smalley, American
- “You just have to continue to try to hit good shots, and most of the pins today were, I mean, kind of absurd.” — Scottie Scheffler, world No. 1
- “If you're in the right spot you can make a putt, but it's really hard to get it close,” — Chris Gotterup, American
- “My birdie putt hung on the lip for a while, and then the wind blew it in,” — Hideki Matsuyama, 2021 Masters champion
What’s Next
Round 3 starts Saturday; the tight leaderboard means any of the 58 contenders could surge for the Wanamaker Trophy.
