Story perspectives

Netanyahu, Minister Sue NYT Over Palestinian Abuse Claims

5/19/2026

Center

Netanyahu Sues NYT

The New York Times called Israel’s lawsuit threat a “well-worn political playbook” to suppress independent journalism.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Gideon Saar will sue New York Times over Nicholas Kristof’s claim of sexual abuse of Palestinian detainees.
Israeli officials said Kristof used Hamas sources and timed the piece to undermine a report.
Experts said Israeli defamation law demands proof of truth, making suits harder than U.S. law.

Right

Israel Sues NYT

Around 300 demonstrators with Israeli and U.S. flags rallied outside the New York Times building in Manhattan, denouncing the column.
Israel announced it will sue the New York Times for article alleging sexual abuse, calling it a “well-worn political playbook”.
Times journalists doubted the column’s sourcing, saying graphic claims likely failed editorial standards.
Canine expert Michael S. Gould said training dogs to rape prisoners is anatomically impossible.

History

Historical Context

The 1971 Supreme Court ruling in New York Times Co. v. United States rejected Nixon’s attempt to block the Pentagon Papers, building on Near v. Minnesota’s ban on prior restraint. That precedent on press freedom underpins Israel’s current defamation suit against the Times, filed by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and minister Gideon Saar, and could reshape global libel standards.

1 of 3

Netanyahu Sues NYT

The New York Times called Israel’s lawsuit threat a “well-worn political playbook” to suppress independent journalism.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Gideon Saar will sue New York Times over Nicholas Kristof’s claim of sexual abuse of Palestinian detainees.
Israeli officials said Kristof used Hamas sources and timed the piece to undermine a report.
Experts said Israeli defamation law demands proof of truth, making suits harder than U.S. law.

1 / 3