Story perspectives

Judge Orders White House Compliance with Records Act

5/21/2026

Center

Bates Orders Records

The opinion opened with a quotation from George Orwell’s novel “1984,” highlighting the court’s view of the administration’s record-keeping.
U.S. District Judge John Bates ordered White House Office and staff to comply with the Presidential Records Act, effective May 26.
Ruling noted Office of Legal Counsel declared Presidential Records Act unconstitutional, risking compliance for records.
American Oversight and American Historical Association said order affirms ownership and demanded a May 28 report.

Left

Bates Orders Records

Judge John D. Bates blocked a Justice Department memo that claimed White House texts were private property, underscoring public record-keeping.
President Donald Trump’s White House was ordered by Judge John D. Bates, Washington, D.C., to preserve all records, including texts.
The ruling invoked the 1978 Presidential Records Act, a post-Watergate law ensuring transparency.
Judge Bates noted no president, including Trump’s term, declared the act unconstitutional, a temporary check.

1 of 2

Bates Orders Records

The opinion opened with a quotation from George Orwell’s novel “1984,” highlighting the court’s view of the administration’s record-keeping.
U.S. District Judge John Bates ordered White House Office and staff to comply with the Presidential Records Act, effective May 26.
Ruling noted Office of Legal Counsel declared Presidential Records Act unconstitutional, risking compliance for records.
American Oversight and American Historical Association said order affirms ownership and demanded a May 28 report.

1 / 2