Story perspectives

NYT Defends Kristof Column Amid Protests, Subscriber Cancellations

5/23/2026

Left

NYT Defends Kristof

The New York Times publicly defended Nicholas Kristof’s column, asserting its opinion section follows rigorous fact-checking and accuracy standards.
Nicholas Kristof published a May 11 opinion piece alleging systematic sexual abuse of Palestinian detainees in Israel.
Opinion editor Kathleen Kingsbury reported testimonies were corroborated by independent sources and found no errors.
Protests outside the New York Times offices led several subscribers to cancel their memberships.

Right

Kristof Accuses Abuse

An Israeli commission released a report with 10,000+ photos, 1,800 hours of video and 430 testimonies documenting Hamas-committed sexual violence.
Nicholas Kristof published a May 11 opinion piece alleging systematic sexual abuse of Palestinian prisoners in Israel.
Benjamin Netanyahu and Gideon Sa’ar called the op-ed a lie and vowed a defamation suit.
Critics said Kristof’s claims relied on Hamas-linked testimony and an allegation of dogs raping prisoners.

Blindspot

Right coverage emphasized the Israeli civil commission’s extensive report—over 10,000 photos, 1,800 hours of video and 430 testimonies documenting Hamas-committed sexual violence—absent from Left coverage.
Right coverage noted Prime Minister Netanyahu and Foreign Minister Sa’ar labeling the op-ed a “hideous, distorted lie” and threatening a defamation lawsuit, which Left coverage did not include.

History

Historical Context

The 1971 Pentagon Papers case saw the Supreme Court reject a prior-restraint injunction in a 6-3 ruling, protecting The New York Times’ publication of a 7,000-page classified study. That precedent of press freedom underpins today’s controversy over Nicholas Kristof’s May 11 op-ed on Palestinian detainee abuse, which Israeli leaders such as Benjamin Netanyahu have condemned as biased.

1 of 4

NYT Defends Kristof

The New York Times publicly defended Nicholas Kristof’s column, asserting its opinion section follows rigorous fact-checking and accuracy standards.
Nicholas Kristof published a May 11 opinion piece alleging systematic sexual abuse of Palestinian detainees in Israel.
Opinion editor Kathleen Kingsbury reported testimonies were corroborated by independent sources and found no errors.
Protests outside the New York Times offices led several subscribers to cancel their memberships.

1 / 4