Story perspectives

Judge Rules Trump Trans Military Ban Unconstitutional, Blocks Enforcement

6/2/2026

50 10

Summary

Story summary

U.S. District Judge Robert Leon Wilkins said the Trump administration’s transgender military ban violates the Constitution because it shows animus and lacks evidence.
The D.C. Circuit split 2-1, with Judges Judith Rogers and Robert Leon Wilkins finding the ban likely breaches constitutional guarantees.
Wilkins partially blocked the 2025 policy, issuing an injunction for active-duty plaintiffs while the Pentagon may still bar transgender enlistments.

History

Historical Context

The “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” ban, imposed by the Clinton administration in February 1994, kept openly gay, lesbian and bisexual Americans out of the armed forces for more than 17 years. After President Obama, Defense Secretary Leon Panetta and Chairman Mike Mullen certified its repeal in July 2011, the policy ended on September 20 2011, setting a legal precedent that judges now cite while evaluating the 2025 transgender service ban.

1 of 2

Story summary

U.S. District Judge Robert Leon Wilkins said the Trump administration’s transgender military ban violates the Constitution because it shows animus and lacks evidence.
The D.C. Circuit split 2-1, with Judges Judith Rogers and Robert Leon Wilkins finding the ban likely breaches constitutional guarantees.
Wilkins partially blocked the 2025 policy, issuing an injunction for active-duty plaintiffs while the Pentagon may still bar transgender enlistments.

1 / 2