Full Breakdown
Massapequa Stabbing Death of Robert Carragher
6/3/2026, 5:59:29 AM
Stabbing Incident and Immediate Aftermath
Monday early morning, 28-year-old Robert Michael Carragher Jr. was stabbed in the neck in the basement apartment of his parents’ home on Beaumont Avenue in Massapequa. Police arrived at 1:30 a.m., found the victim with a neck wound, and his parents attempted to stop the bleeding. He died in his father’s arms.
Background and Relationship
Suspect Kristin Sculley, 22, was an acquaintance of Carragher for several years. The two met at a bar the night before, returned to his home, and spent several hours together before Sculley stabbed Carragher while he slept. No romantic relationship was confirmed.
Key Figures
Key individuals include victim Robert Michael Carragher Jr., suspect Kristin Sculley, Detective Lt. George Darienzo, Deputy Homicide Bureau Chief Ania Pulaski, defense attorney Mindy Plotkin, and friends Louis Ambrosio and Thomas Maloney.
Timeline
Night before Monday the two met at a bar and traveled to Carragher’s home. At 1:30 a.m. on Monday a 911 call prompted police to find Carragher with a neck wound and Sculley hiding in the basement with a pocketknife. Carragher was pronounced dead at the scene. On Tuesday, June 2, Sculley was arraigned, pleaded not guilty, and was remanded without bail.
Data and Legal Context
The victim was 28; the suspect, 22. Sculley faces a second-degree murder charge carrying a possible sentence of 15 years to life. Police recovered a pocketknife believed to be the weapon. Investigators noted possible drug use but found no drugs.
Official Statements
Police said Sculley “became angry” and used a knife she brought, calling the act unprovoked and noting no motive. They emphasized the tragedy of a son dying in his father’s arms.
Criticism and Opposition
Attorney Mindy Plotkin argued that self-defense should be examined, suggesting Sculley may have perceived an immediate threat.
Verbatim Quotes
- “The defendant took out a knife that she brought with her and plunged it into the victim's neck, puncturing an artery in his neck,” — Ania Pulaski, Deputy Homicide Bureau Chief
- “He died in his father's arms,” — George Darienzo, Detective Lieutenant
- “No family should ever have to bear witness to their son being killed in that manner.” — George Darienzo, Detective Lieutenant
- “An amazing friend, good person. He didn't deserve to go out like this,” — Louis Ambrosio, friend
Conflicting Reports and Gaps
Initial coverage identified only a “28-year-old man”; later reports named Robert Michael Carragher Jr. Police have not disclosed a motive; drug involvement remains unclear. The relationship was not established.
What’s Next
The case will continue through the court process, with further proceedings expected. Investigators continue reviewing surveillance footage and forensic evidence.
