Story perspectives

Penn Station Redesign Unveiled, Tax Grab Bill Stirs Outcry

6/9/2026

Summary

Amtrak Unveils Renovations

Amtrak and MTA officials unveiled Penn Station renovation renderings without revealing the $7-$8 billion cost range.
Developers propose $250 million per year in availability payments from each tenant railroad for 50 years and $500 million to James Dolan to demolish the Hulu Theater.
An amendment to the Build America 250 Act could let Amtrak seize property-tax revenue, which critics say could let Vornado redevelop the area and shift billions of New York City taxes.

Summary

Trump Takes Control

U.S. President Donald Trump seized authority over the Penn Station redevelopment last year, shifting control.
Architect Vishaan Chakrabarti proposes a façade resembling the Farley Building, sweeping staircases and a 450-foot glass concourse.
Amtrak CEO Andy Byford says funding is under $250 million and that Amtrak will pursue grants and loans for $7 billion rebuild.
Governor Kathy Hochul announced New York will not fund the project and withdrew more than $1 billion previously pledged.

Summary

Roth Redesigns Station

Vornado Realty Trust, led by Steve Roth, heads Penn Transformation Partners consortium redesigning the station with a 50-foot ceiling and gold-plated clock.
A stone wall near escalators will bear a presidential seal and “President Donald J. Trump” inscription.
Renovation will raise commuter space from 65,000 to 170,000 square feet, a 165 % increase.
Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy called the project a “Golden Age of Transportation” ushered in by President Donald J. Trump.

Summary

Penn Transformation Renovates

The six-year renovation will begin at the end of 2027.
Penn Transformation Partners, a joint venture led by Halmar and Skanska, will manage construction.
A new 8th Avenue entrance modeled on federal architecture will open in the first phase.
The existing 7th Avenue and 31st Street entrances will be completely redesigned.
Because the federal government will fund most of the $7-$8 billion cost, fares will not be raised.

History

Historical Context

The original Pennsylvania Station opened on November 27 1910 and its head house was razed in October 1963, igniting a national preservation outcry that prompted New York’s Landmarks Preservation Commission in 1965 and saved Grand Central Terminal. Today, Amtrak, Vornado Realty and Governor Kathy Hochul are pursuing a $7-$8 billion Penn Station rebuild, echoing that earlier fight for civic space.

1 of 5

Amtrak Unveils Renovations

Amtrak and MTA officials unveiled Penn Station renovation renderings without revealing the $7-$8 billion cost range.
Developers propose $250 million per year in availability payments from each tenant railroad for 50 years and $500 million to James Dolan to demolish the Hulu Theater.
An amendment to the Build America 250 Act could let Amtrak seize property-tax revenue, which critics say could let Vornado redevelop the area and shift billions of New York City taxes.

1 / 5