Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

Nintendo Pays €35 Million Fine Over Faulty Switch Joy-Cons

6/9/2026

46 3 Full Breakdown

Summary

Nintendo Pays Fine

Nintendo will pay a €35 million fine to settle a claim over faulty Switch Joy-Cons.
The 2020 claim by a French consumer group alleged planned obsolescence and cited thousands of drift complaints.
France’s DGCCRF said Nintendo Europe failed to inform consumers, commenting only in 2020, which pushed buyers to buy new controllers instead of free repairs.
Nintendo pledged in 2023 to repair or replace faulty Joy-Cons for free after warranty expiration.

Summary

Nintendo Faces Obsolescence

UFC-Que Choisir publicly warned in 2019 that Nintendo might be practicing planned obsolescence before filing a formal complaint in 2020.
Planned obsolescence is defined as designing products with a limited useful life to prompt earlier consumer replacement.
DGCCRF investigators determined that Nintendo knew of Joy-Con drift and broader controller responsiveness problems in the original Switch as early as 2018.

History

Historical Context

European bans on landfill e-waste in the 1990s spurred a recycling industry, culminating in the EU’s Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment Directive of February 2003, which obliges producers such as Philips and Sony to finance free-of-charge collection and achieve at least 4 kg per capita annually. The 2020 French complaint against Nintendo shows how that regulatory legacy now pressures manufacturers to address product defects.

1 of 3

Nintendo Pays Fine

Nintendo will pay a €35 million fine to settle a claim over faulty Switch Joy-Cons.
The 2020 claim by a French consumer group alleged planned obsolescence and cited thousands of drift complaints.
France’s DGCCRF said Nintendo Europe failed to inform consumers, commenting only in 2020, which pushed buyers to buy new controllers instead of free repairs.
Nintendo pledged in 2023 to repair or replace faulty Joy-Cons for free after warranty expiration.

1 / 3