Story perspectives

Judge Grants Injunction, Lets Clemson Receiver Play Over NCAA

6/13/2026

Summary

Tristan Smith Wins

American judge granted Clemson receiver Tristan Smith an injunction against the NCAA, letting him play this season.
Judge Jessica A. Salvini said Smith’s case matches those of players Malik Benson and Diego Pavia, got eligibility.
She noted distinction was that Smith’s Division I season is in 2025-26, not 2024-25.
Smith sued the NCAA in January after a waiver denial; attorney Darren Heitner called it a win and said the Five-Year Rule did not hold up.
He transferred to Southeast Missouri State 2024 and Clemson 2025.
Smith thanked on X and started games with 24 catches for 239 yards and a touchdown.

Summary

Smith Faces NIL Loss

Smith’s case projects a $300,000-$600,000 loss in NIL earnings if he misses the 2026 season.
An ankle injury kept Smith out of spring practice; Judge Salvini cited the June 8, 2026 Texas Tech quarterback Brendan Sorsby injunction as courts limit NCAA eligibility rules.
Smith arrived as one of three transfers joining Clemson in 2025, adding to a lineup that now includes Bryant Wesco Jr., T.J. Moore, Tyler Brown and Cole Turner.

Summary

Tristan Smith Eligibility

Tristan Smith began at a junior college, played at FCS Southeast Missouri State, then transferred to Clemson, illustrating a junior-college-to-Power Five pathway.
The NCAA gave the 2024-25 graduating class a blanket extra year of eligibility for junior-college players, but excluded the 2025-26 cohort that includes Smith.
Smith’s eligibility dispute shows how class-based rules can create disparities for junior-college transfers and may shape recruiting.

Summary

Tristan Smith Eligible

Tristan Smith will be cleared to suit up for Clemson’s season opener on Sept. 5 against LSU.
Clemson expects to expand Smith’s role in its offense after his 2025 production of 239 yards on 24 receptions.
The injunction is conditioned on the NCAA posting a $5,000 surety bond before the order becomes effective.

History

Historical Context

In August 2014, Judge Claudia Wilken ruled that the NCAA’s ban on paying athletes violated antitrust law in O’Bannon v. NCAA, ordering schools could place up to $5,000 in a trust for each player. That precedent underpins Judge Jessica A. Salvini’s 2024 injunction for transfer receiver Tristan Smith, which challenges the NCAA’s five-year transfer rule and requires a $5,000 surety bond.

1 of 5

Tristan Smith Wins

American judge granted Clemson receiver Tristan Smith an injunction against the NCAA, letting him play this season.
Judge Jessica A. Salvini said Smith’s case matches those of players Malik Benson and Diego Pavia, got eligibility.
She noted distinction was that Smith’s Division I season is in 2025-26, not 2024-25.
Smith sued the NCAA in January after a waiver denial; attorney Darren Heitner called it a win and said the Five-Year Rule did not hold up.
He transferred to Southeast Missouri State 2024 and Clemson 2025.
Smith thanked on X and started games with 24 catches for 239 yards and a touchdown.

1 / 5