Story perspectives

Midtown Evacuations Ended; Officials Cite Column Buckling, Fines

7/9/2026

Center

City Officials Lift Evacuations

City officials reduced the Midtown “frozen zone” and lifted most building evacuations after monitoring showed no further column movement.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani said two columns buckled in the 37-story former Pfizer building at 235 East 42nd Street, prompting evacuations.
The Department of Buildings recorded seven violations and $32,000 in fines July–December 2025.
Developer MetroLoft blamed added weight from widening the top fifteen floors and pledged an investigation.

Right

Berman Declares Safe

Developer Nathan Berman called the beam failure a freak accident and insisted the skyscraper’s structure remains sound.
A beam failure caused movement in a skyscraper, prompting Department of Buildings crews to install shoring and declare tower stable.
No injuries occurred, with all workers accounted for and a school of 400 students evacuated.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani called serious while FDNY Chief John Esposito warned collapse would be localized.

Blindspot

Center coverage emphasized the Department of Buildings’ record of seven violations and more than $32,000 in fines, a detail absent from Right coverage.
Center coverage highlighted MetroLoft’s explanation that added weight from widening the top fifteen floors caused the buckling, which Right coverage did not mention.

History

Historical Context

On June 29 1995 the five-story Sampoong Department Store in Seoul collapsed, killing 502 people after Lee Joon’s illegal removal of columns and addition of a fifth floor weakened the flat-slab structure. The disaster followed a rapid post-1988 Olympic building boom that left oversight lax, prompting the Jan 5 1995 Special Act on Safety Management of Structures and tighter inspections after the 1994 Seongsu Bridge collapse.

1 of 4

City Officials Lift Evacuations

City officials reduced the Midtown “frozen zone” and lifted most building evacuations after monitoring showed no further column movement.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani said two columns buckled in the 37-story former Pfizer building at 235 East 42nd Street, prompting evacuations.
The Department of Buildings recorded seven violations and $32,000 in fines July–December 2025.
Developer MetroLoft blamed added weight from widening the top fifteen floors and pledged an investigation.

1 / 4