Video Footage Undermines ICE and CBP Accounts of Recent Immigration-Enforcement Shootings

Between January 2025 and March 2025, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and Customs and Border Protection (CBP) agents were involved in at least four high-profile shootings that officials described as responses to “weaponized” vehicles or armed threats. The incidents occurred in Houston, Texas; Minneapolis, Minnesota; and South Padre Island, Texas, and involved Lorenzo Salgado Araujo, Renée Nicole Good, Julio Cesar Sosa-Celis, Alex Pretti, and Ruben Ray Martinez. DHS statements repeatedly framed the victims as actively endangering officers.

Newsweek

• DHS spokesperson said Araujo “weaponized” his vehicle before a federal agent in Houston fatally shot him.

Newsweek

• DHS officials asserted Good “used her SUV as a weapon and attempted to run over an officer.”

Newsweek

• Federal officials claimed Sosa-Celis was shot while agents “fearing for his life and safety” after being “ambushed by three individuals.”

Newsweek

• DHS said Pretti “approached Border Patrol officers with a semiautomatic handgun and violently resisted attempts to disarm him,” adding he intended to do “maximum damage” and “massacre law enforcement.”

Newsweek

• In the Martinez case, DHS alleged the driver “intentionally struck a federal agent and left him on the hood of the car” before Agent Jack Stevens opened fire.

Newsweek

Multiple by-stander recordings released after the incidents contradict key elements of the official accounts:

Newsweek

• Footage of Good shows the SUV moving forward after an officer opened the door, with the driver turning the steering wheel away before shots were fired; the officer is not knocked down.

Newsweek

• Grainy video of the Sosa-Celis encounter shows a man discarding a shovel before any contact, and no clear evidence of a “shovel attack.” Prosecutors later dismissed charges, and ICE agent Christian Castro faced assault charges for a false report.

Newsweek

• In Pretti’s case, videos capture agents shoving individuals, pepper-spraying Pretti, and tackling him without him brandishing a firearm; a handgun matching the described weapon appears only after he is restrained.

Newsweek

• Martinez’s body-camera footage shows his Ford Fusion stationary, brake lights on, and the vehicle moving at very low speed when shots were fired; the car does not strike an agent.

Newsweek

Charges against Sosa-Celis and Alfredo Alejandro Aljorna were withdrawn; Minnesota prosecutors charged Agent Christian Castro with assault and false reporting. A Texas grand jury declined to indict Agent Jack Stevens in the Martinez shooting. Former officials—including Kristi Noem, Tricia McLaughlin, and Gregory Bovino—departed the administration amid controversy over the Pretti narrative.

Newsweek

• DHS’s claim of 182 vehicle attacks against ICE and CBP officers since January 2025 has not been independently verified.

Newsweek

• Discrepancies between agency statements and video evidence leave open questions about the exact sequence of events and the justification for lethal force in each case.

Newsweek

Verbatim Quotes

Newsweek

• “weaponized” his vehicle before a federal agent in Houston fatally shot him. — DHS spokesperson

Newsweek

• “She used her SUV as a weapon and attempted to run over an officer.” — DHS officials

Newsweek

• “fearing for his life and safety” after being “ambushed by three individuals.” — Federal officials

Newsweek

• “He approached Border Patrol officers with a semiautomatic handgun and violently resisted attempts to disarm him.” — DHS

Newsweek

• “He intended to do ‘maximum damage’ and ‘massacre law enforcement.’” — Kristi Noem

Newsweek

• “10 gunshots were fired in less than five seconds.” — Video analysis

Newsweek