Scott Foley Responds to Prime Video Cancellation of “It’s Not Like That”

Amazon Prime Video announced the cancellation of the drama series “It’s Not Like That” after its eight-episode first season, which premiered on Jan. 25. The decision was reported on Wednesday, 2026, following the show’s removal from the platform’s lineup.

Variety Magazine

Created by Ian Deitchman and Kristin Rusk Robinson, the series follows a newly divorced woman and a recently widowed pastor as they navigate single life and parenthood. The cast includes Erinn Hayes, J.R. Ramirez, Caleb Baumann, Cary Christopher, Liv Lindell, Leven Miranda, Cassidy Paul, and Michaela Russell. Within roughly six weeks, the series entered Prime Video’s Top 10, reaching as high as the third or fourth position, and earned a 100 % rating on Rotten Tomatoes according to the show’s lead actor.

Variety Magazine

Lead actor Scott Foley posted an Instagram video expressing disappointment over the cancellation while emphasizing gratitude for the opportunity to create the series. He thanked the cast, crew, and viewers, noting that the show remains available for streaming despite its cancellation. Foley also indicated a willingness to collaborate with his colleagues again in future projects.

Variety Magazine

• “Well, after six or so weeks in Prime Video’s top 10, and I think getting as high as like three or four, [and] really great reviews, I think we have like 100% on Rotten Tomatoes, our little show called ‘It’s Not Like That’ has been canceled at Amazon Prime,” — Scott Foley

Variety Magazine

• “I think I’m just I’m disappointed, obviously, but I’m so grateful for the chance, right? I got to make a show I’m so proud of with people I grew to like a lot, and now we don’t get to make it anymore, and you don’t get to watch it.” — Scott Foley

Variety Magazine

• “If you watched it, thank you. I appreciate it. If you didn’t, still on Amazon Prime. You can check it out. It’s not going to change the cancellation, but I wanted to thank everybody who took the time to check it out. Whether you found it on your own, whether it was a recommendation you saw on social media, it’s appreciated. So thank you. And to the entire cast and crew of ‘It’s Not Like That,’ I loved making a show with you, and I would work with you again and again and again.” — Scott Foley

Variety Magazine

• “If you watched it, thank you. I appreciate it. If you didn’t, still on Amazon Prime. You can check it out. It’s not going to change the cancellation, but I wanted to thank everybody who took the time to check it out. Whether you found it on your own, whether it was a recommendation you saw on social media, it’s appreciated. So thank you. And to the entire cast and crew of ‘It’s Not Like That,’ I loved making a show with you, and I would work with you again and again and again.” — Scott Foley

Variety Magazine

The cancellation underscores that strong viewership metrics and critical acclaim do not guarantee renewal on streaming platforms. Amazon Prime Video has not issued a public comment beyond the removal of the series from its roster. No further information about potential future projects for the cast or creators has been released.

Variety Magazine