Full Breakdown
Takeaway Owner Convicted of Fraudulently Claiming Disability Benefits
7/10/2026, 2:18:28 PM
Fraudulent Claim Uncovered
Julie Smith, 47, of Wishaw, Lanarkshire, admitted to providing false or misleading information to obtain £13,720.17 in disability benefits from Social Security Scotland between August 2022 and March 2024. While claiming she could not walk more than 20 metres and required assistance for basic tasks, investigators filmed her cooking, serving customers, and driving alone to shop for supplies for JM Munchies, a takeaway she operated in nearby Coatbridge.
Court Findings and Sentencing
Hamilton Sheriff Court concluded that Smith’s statements were “fairly blatant” and constituted a serious offence. Sheriff Maria Kicinski ordered a 50-day electronic tagging requirement, restricting Smith to her home from 7 p.m. to 7 a.m. The court noted that Smith has not yet repaid the claimed amount, though deductions from future benefits will be applied. She remains in receipt of benefits pending those deductions.
Official Responses
Prosecutor Cameron Murdoch highlighted the discrepancy between Smith’s disability claim and the surveillance evidence, emphasizing that she “was seen preparing and cooking food and serving customers while standing for long periods.” Defence lawyer Frances Taylor acknowledged the unpaid sum but stressed that Smith continues to receive benefits, with repayments to be deducted. Sheriff Kicinski described the case as a “serious offence involving defrauding the public purse over a period of years.”
Verbatim Quotes
- “The accused had claimed she was unable to cook meals without her daughter's help. She said she couldn't wash or bathe herself and was unable to walk further than 20 metres. ?” — Cameron Murdoch, Prosecutor
- “She was seen preparing and cooking food and serving customers while standing for long periods.” — Cameron Murdoch, Prosecutor
- “Sheriff Maria Kicinski told first offender Smith: "This is a serious offence involving defrauding the public purse over a period of years.” — Sheriff Maria Kicinski
- “ Defence lawyer Frances Taylor said Smith has not yet paid back the money but she is still in receipt of benefits and deductions will be made.” — Frances Taylor, Defence Lawyer
Implications
The case underscores the vigilance of Social Security Scotland’s fraud investigation unit and illustrates the legal consequences for individuals who misrepresent disability status to obtain public funds. Electronic tagging and benefit deductions serve as deterrents intended to protect the public purse.
